Wii Only Owners:  If you had to buy an HD console, but could only buy one, which would it be and why?

My answer:  I think a 360, because of Live, Netflix, and it would be the cheapest way for me to play the two titles I'm interested in most -- Bioshock & FFXIII.  The only thing really pulling me to PS3 at the moment is MGS4.

How 'bout you?

I say PS3, 'cause of teh cell-and Blu-Ray. And LBP. And Uncharted. And Motorstorm>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Forenza

Sony. It's a more dependable machine and has better graphics (this is the reason to buy a HD system).

 I can't piece through the rrod conversations -- hard to tell who's trolling & who's not -- are new 360s still having problems?  Or can you generally trust one if you buy it today?

you do know bioshock is also for ps3 and ff 13 for 360 might be a bad version unlike the ps3 version and ps3 also has ff 13 versus exclusive

360.

Not really. I certainly have never even heard of a Jasper RRoDing.

As for games, you want a 360 but don't want Tales of Vesperia and Star Ocean 4? ;_; 

PS3.

If I HAD to, I'd buy a 360. Great RPGs.

But since I don't have to, none. I have a PC :)

It's hard, but i would say xbox 360, it's cheaper, and it's reliable now. It's close call though, i like games on ps3, a bit more, though.