If only the 360 controller had a working d-pad....

360is best ever 3d controller ... then snes for 2d

1) 360 Controller
2) Dream Cast Contoller + vmu
3) Gamecube

Best Controller ever, it really revolutionized things.

The Wii Remote.

Snes controller I suppose, perfect for what it was.

SNES, Logitech Playstation Controller not the Playstation normal one, and 360 if D pad worked.

Who cares about D-Pad in this 7th generation?
Seriously?
My D-Pad on my 360 is rarely used, and when it does... it's for rare inventory action and stuffs...

I prefer to have 2 great analog sticks (with thumb holes) with natural position across the controller... than a wonderful D-Pad (on my PS3) but mediocre analogs sticks that just doesn't feel right for my hand.

D-Pad is a small consideration in today's gaming.

I know I'm going to be alone on this, but N64. The purple atomic controller brings back memories........

If the Dpad on the 360 controller was fixed it would be the perfect controller. Extremely ergonomic.