By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft Discussion - Eternal Sonata Screens or What Great Cel Shaded Graphics Look Like (no 56k)

mrstickball said:
Yes, lets keep throwing dumb Wii pictures in the threads from people that don't own X360s and HDTVs.

How many of you, arguing that Wii games look better, even own the games your promoting and bashing?

I own a Wii and an HDTV.  I'm working on the Xbox 360, but won't have the money till around November (got a lot of extra bills right now).  However, why don't you contribute to the discussion rather than attack the posters themsevles?  Are you disagreeing that there are some Wii games that look close to 360 quality?



Around the Network
mrstickball said:
Yes, lets keep throwing dumb Wii pictures in the threads from people that don't own X360s and HDTVs.

How many of you, arguing that Wii games look better, even own the games your promoting and bashing?

I agree... I know that everytime I see a thread that compares graphics between the Wii and 360 or turns into one it's just going to end up being ridiculous.  The Wii's strength is not in graphics and people need to start realizing and accepting that.



How did this turn into a pissing contest between the 360 and the Wii?

Lets talk about awesome cell shaded games.

Jean D'arc: http://www.gametrailers.com/player/20922.html

FFT:TWotL: http://www.gametrailers.com/player/23013.html

Eternal Sonata: http://www.gametrailers.com/player/20641.html

Luminous Arc: http://www.gametrailers.com/player/16859.html

 



Wow links to cutscenes... What point were you trying to make?



Legend11 said:
Wow links to cutscenes... What point were you trying to make?

That you can have good games on all systems. I didn't realise that taking sides was mandatory.

The only vid not to include in game footage was FFT (ES uses gaem engine). I added that because I really like the art style.



Around the Network

naz - Thats exactly my issue.

You DONT own a X360. You can compare game X and Y to eachother in screens (and the majority of the games you posted for the Wii aren't even out, so there's no way you can confirm they're even ingame).

Please for the love of God, own an X360 or atleast extensively play one and it's various games before trying to make statments that are so pro-Wii and anti-X360.

This thread has degenerated into an idiotic Wii-chest beating exercice for Nfans. This was *supposed* to be an X360 chat about how good looking Eternal Sonata is, and it quickly became infested with Wii owners. Why the crap do you feel the need to come attack our games saying they can be done on the Wii? I have never seen cklmb, nor myself, nor Legend or Dolla ever come into YOUR forum to attack the graphics, or qualities of YOUR games.

And most importantly, your trying to stress ART direction on many things rather than graphics. I would agree that some games have great art direction and are "prettier" than others. But graphics are mere extentions of advanced lines of code involving more polygons, better lighting, and various computational processes. Your really not trying to compare those, as the X360, like the PS3, like the PC, has alot more ability to produce those graphical things than the Wii is. That's a certainty.

Now if you want to argue if a game like SSBB or SPM have better art direction, and because they are more colorful, "look better", thats fine. But thats merely your opinion. And only your opinion. You can't count the poly's on any of those pictures, nor colors, nor will Nintendo give specs out. There's a reason behind that.

I'm locking what was a great thread about a great game. Thanks to you Nintendo fans that just want to belittle everyone else's great games. Thanks for becoming the new childish Sony fans that feel like *everything* revolves around the Wii - because God forbid the X360 or PS3 ever dare to trounce in the areas of colorful, good art direction, actual storylines, or good gameplay that appearently only the Wii offers.



Back from the dead, I'm afraid.