By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - So...being realistic...XBOX360 made Ps3 flop this year

It is a flop from the software point of view... less bad from the Blue-Ray player ... .euh ... console point of view.



 

Evan Wells (Uncharted 2): I think the differences that you see between any two games has much more to do with the developer than whether it’s on the Xbox or PS3.

Around the Network
Paul_Warren said:
"I have a Falcon and I doubt it will ever happen."

Well, then, let's see how many you play after Microsoft gives up game development for the 360 some time in early 2009 to concentrate their efforts towards the new console they have coming out next November much as they did during the switch from the original 'box to the 360.

 

you have no clue don't you.

MS said so many times, xbox is sell at a loss just like PS3 nowadays, and because most of it chip are from NVIDIA, NVIDIA won't reduce it price at that time, and MS don't have any right to produce it's own chip at that time.

so better for them to cut xbox, rather that give them more looses.

this time is different, MS has any right to manufacture the xbox 360.

even if xbox 720 is released, Xbx 360 still being produced as long there is demand.

and remember MS will perfected software emulation so transition to xbox 720 will be smooth.

 

not like PS3, they made a huge noises about 100% BC, but right now it is 0% BC, only PS1 titles.

only old PS3 model, and several model supporting BC, and they don't even bothered to create software emul

they have to concentrated on Home , again another failed product from Sony, 2 years and we dn't know when

home will be released.



dejelek,

Yeah, I have a clue. Gears of War 3 will be the flagship title for the next MS console. I know that a lot of you are saying, "The next XBOX won't be out until 2012 or 2025." But the truth of the matter is it has to release in a timely fashion for Epic and Gears of War 3. Microsoft doesn't have a bigger franchise headed into the next gen and they don't really have another system seller at this point in time because the Fable series isn't popular enough and Halo is losing steam. The latest the next 'box can be released is 2011, the earliest is 2009. And 2010 is probably the right year.



My most anticipated games:  Whatever Hideo Kojima is going to do next, Final Fantasy XIII, Final Fantasy Versus XIII, Gran Turismo 5, Alan Wake, Wii Sports Resort.  Cave Story Wiiware.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqqLMgbtrB8

Paul_Warren said:

dejelek,

Yeah, I have a clue. Gears of War 3 will be the flagship title for the next MS console. I know that a lot of you are saying, "The next XBOX won't be out until 2012 or 2025." But the truth of the matter is it has to release in a timely fashion for Epic and Gears of War 3. Microsoft doesn't have a bigger franchise headed into the next gen and they don't really have another system seller at this point in time because the Fable series isn't popular enough and Halo is losing steam. The latest the next 'box can be released is 2011, the earliest is 2009. And 2010 is probably the right year.

 

lol, you lost all your credibility in one sentence. September 2007, that's all I say. 



Paul_Warren said:

dejelek,

Yeah, I have a clue. Gears of War 3 will be the flagship title for the next MS console. I know that a lot of you are saying, "The next XBOX won't be out until 2012 or 2025." But the truth of the matter is it has to release in a timely fashion for Epic and Gears of War 3. Microsoft doesn't have a bigger franchise headed into the next gen and they don't really have another system seller at this point in time because the Fable series isn't popular enough and Halo is losing steam. The latest the next 'box can be released is 2011, the earliest is 2009. And 2010 is probably the right year.

 

multiplatform is the key, why MS have to rely on 1st party, if every multiplat will be better on xbox 360, and better on sales too.

2008, Sony already releasing 1st party, LBP, R2, MGS4 , Socomm, do you pleased with sony software sales from 1st party titles ?

i bet as soon as COD hit sale on PS3, it will have better sales than R2

 

 

if MGS4 sales is not that high , what made you think KZ2 will made it any better,

i also think, the way they made it to beta, long way from released, will have negative impact.

the hype after the beta will going down, just like R2, people Hypeing R2 to the roof, then bam

the sales not as good as expected.

 

without 1st party titles, there will be Rock Band, Guitar Hero, Sport titles, there will be COD 6

there will be F.E.A.R, there will be RE5, there will be STAR OCEAN , Lost Planet 2 etc, many many more games

 

and flood from PC developer that will happily to ported game for Xbox 360, but not for PS3

 

 

 



Around the Network
Paul_Warren said:

dejelek,

Yeah, I have a clue. Gears of War 3 will be the flagship title for the next MS console.

 

You concentrate too much on flagship titles. If this generation proves anything it is a problem for exclussive titles.

Multi plattform games reduce the risk for developpers and they can earn even more money, as COD, GTA or Assassin's creed demonstrated. The next move will probably be even more compatibility friendly and allow the support for the old and new plattform. At least for the Xbox720 this probly will not be an unfeasable feature, while I don't have a clue how a PS-4 should emulate the old cell.

Such plattforms would probably have FULL HD capabilities and simpler, earsier to use interfaces, to simplify develoipment on the new plattforms. So you could implement the development environment to allow the compilation for the old and new plattform ahnd you could fine tune from this stage on. This would allow a pretty smooth transition anhd while you put more and more money into the support of the new plattform you could still support the old plattform.

Add some money for timed exclussive releases and you have everything you need.

You can look at it as you like, but the push to multi plattform games shifted a lot of power from the hardware production to the software developers. The hardware only a plattform but for the software producers there are three important values: 1, how much does the development cost on this plattform, how many possible customers do I have on this plattform and how much money can I ask for the game.

The big problem for the PS-3is really that you can't use the count of available consoles as the user base for game developers. I use my PS-3 in most casers for BluRay only. I don't really have so much time for games.

On the other hand are the SPUs a big problem in the development process, because they need a totally different code base and they are integrated in a manner that makes it pretty hard to use them in reactive real time applications. Furthermore the normal system RAM is always a limiting factor Especially the time to market is the week point of this plattform.

The Xbox360 is a bit easier because the three basic cores can use the same code base and load balancing is included for free.  And multi cores are standard feature of todays PCs, so the co development for the PC is easier.  Its biggest problems are Resource conflicts. Especially the very fast video RAM is to limited.

From a development standpoint I would say the Xbox 360 is in a better position. Even if it would be in third place most games will be mult plattform based (the HD graphics and animations can be used on both plattforms. Furthermore: to use the SPEs effectively you should use the PPU only. This is nearly exactly the same unit as it is used in each of the thrree cores on the Xbox360 (they have each an additional Altivec Unit).). Even if Microsoft would have to switch to Intel or AMD based chips this difference is manageable as Apple demonstrated with its switch to Intel based machines.

It will pürobably achieve a software compatibility for some games, while other games could be recompiled with slight changes and rereleased at cheaper prices with enhanced capabilities. It should be no problem to release such a plattform between 2010-2012, but it would not mean the end of the Xbox360.

But how would you mange a compatible PS-4? IBM and Toshiba switched their chip developments according to their needs. Game development is not on their aggenda. Everything elsse is based on multi cores, while streaming calculations are more and more exported to the GPU. This is a complete switch from the PS-3 and a complete different plattform.

With such a different transition it is pretty easy to guess which plattform would attract more developers.

While the current PS-3 pushes the BluRay market it also strangles the market for BluRay players, which can be a pretty severe problem in the long run. And every price drop will increase this problem. More and more Hardware developers leave this market, because there is nothing to gain for them.



kars,
The problem with your comment is that you are assuming that just any old games will sell consoles. There are more factors involved than just its quality in determining how well a piece of software will sell. And that has been Sony's problem as of late. Even though Little Big Planet is considered to be the fourteenth best game ever made according to Game Rankings, it isn't selling like Halo or Gears because it is in an unpopular genre. And even though Resistance 2 is as good as Gears 2 according to IGN, it isn't selling at a Gears 2 pace because it never gained the same size fanbase through hype and marketing.

So Microsoft knows that they have a bonafide seller in the next Gears game and they will use that to move their next console. And they will need it do so as the next Microsoft console with all of the tech it will have under the hood wll probably cost at least $500.00 at launch.



My most anticipated games:  Whatever Hideo Kojima is going to do next, Final Fantasy XIII, Final Fantasy Versus XIII, Gran Turismo 5, Alan Wake, Wii Sports Resort.  Cave Story Wiiware.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqqLMgbtrB8

Fei-Hung said:
The gap is not getting bigger, in fact it was getting smaller until MS dropped their price. PS3 is still too pricy in a world where recession has hit many homes and this has made the 360 more accessible to gamers. Neither console is going anywhere fast. 360 was selling better, then the ps3 was selling better and now the 360 is selling better - both are selling well.

games -
1) well the larger the install base, the more they will sell.
2) LBP is a Niche game unlike Gears and Halo
3) Unlike Resistance; Halo and Fable have a huge fan base from the previous gen.
4) Resistance may have been good when it came out, but not many casual gamers were happy since the graphics were naff compared to Gears. So now they doubt the new r2 will be worth buying.
5) Sony hyped a lot of games (heavenly sword, haze, lair to name a few), but reviews as well as some of the hype. So now many gamers doubt if Sony games are really what they are hyped to be. Unlike the 360, most games apart from too human did live up to the hype.
6) Sony marketing has been shite compared to 360 marketing.

Where you make a mistake is thinking they have won the war. many people do not realise how well the PS3 is selling with its current price compared to the 360 who should be killing the PS3 with the price differential. The question remains, what will happen when and if the PS3 drops by another $100's and becomes more affordable?

Sony have also failed to release any games that have a big fan base. Games such as; GT, Jak and Daxter, Dance mat games, a new PS3 Wipeout, GoW3, Onimusha and twisted metal.

Those games that could have made a difference; GTA, Devil May Cry, FF, tekken and maybe some more have now gone multi platform. meaning, if you are a gamer who can't afford a PS3, you need not worry, a cheaper console is out there who can play the same game!

 

Could not have said it better myself so why try



PS3, WII and 360 all great systems depends on what type of console player you are.

Currently playing Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2, Fallout 3, Halo ODST and Dragon Age Origins is next game

Xbox live:mywiferocks

The only console that flopped this year was the Wii. Oh wait we are not talking about games we are talking about sales. Nevermind.



---

Paul_Warren said:
"while the 360 has consistently delivered."

Yeah the 360 has delivered on one game this year. All the rest were flops.

 

One game? What is this abomination of a fanboy post. Lets just say PS3 and 360 have both delivered quality exclusive and multiplat AAA titles. Stop being such fanboys. If you look at the library of games over the months, Ps3 and 360  are pretty much neck and neck, you can't go wrong with either this year. And even salewise there isn't much in it. PS3 may outsell 360 by next year, but the difference in sales at the end of this gen won't be significant.

In fact i'm pretty sure 360 would have been a more succesful console at the end...360 will outsell Xbox1...PS3 has no chance of going anyway near PS2's sales.



---