1up gives Gears of war 2 10/10 and gives Resistance 2 8.3/10. WTF are they smoking lol, this is the most absurd review i have seen since Eurogamer gave Mgs4 8/10 and Halo 3 10/10 WTF.

1up and Eurogamer are not capable of reviewing games, no offense Gears of war 2 is an amazing game but the 1up review really annoys me, I just can't understand how they can give Gears of war 2 10/10 and R2 8.3/10, in their review they said that Gow2 has flaws but it still received 10/10.

Please also discuss the Eurogamer mgs4 review 8/10 and the halo 3 10/10 WTF?

No offence Halo 3 is not in the same league as Mgs4 any gamer will tell you!

1up gives halo 3 10/10 and Mgs4 9.1/10, this is unacceptable. The review system is broken most reviewers favour x360 games this is a simple fact. What happened to fair and balanced reviews.

Edit - Mods please dont ban me if this thread is breaching rules, please message me!

1up gives Gears of war 2 10/10 and gives Resistance 2 8.3/10. WTF are they smoking lol, this most absurd review i have seen since Eurogamer gave Mgs4 8/10 and Halo 3 10/10 WTF.

1up and Eurogamer are not capable of reviewing games, no offense Gears of war 2 is an amazing game but the 1up review really annoys me, I just can't understand how they can give Gears of war 2 10/10 and R2 8.3/10, in their review they said that Gow2 has flaws but it still received 10/10. Maybe Microsoft paid them who knows lol

Please also discuss the Eurogamer mgs4 review 8/10 and the halo 3 10/10 WTF?

Edit - Mods please dont ban me if this thread is breaching rules, please message me!

mods please lock.....we have NUMEROUS threads discussing GEOW vs RES 2

thanks :)

We need a rants forum where the mods can move threads like this.

I've played neither, and thus my opinion is not valid yet.

I've played neither, and thus my opinion is not valid yet.

          Agreed, we all need a nice little place to rant, every once and a while.....this thread proves it!

^ I see what you did there.

WTF?

I am not comparing them cant you read, i was talking about the review system. Go learn how to read before your run crying to the mods!

/agree

And no need to worry about being banned for making a thread like this, just trying to keep the number of R2 and Gears 2 threads down.  :-p