You know, it really wouldnt make a whole lot of sense for the classic controller to have rumble feature. Its basically for classic games (the name kinda says that) and the classic games never had rumble to them.

 The Wiimote is without doubt my favorite.   It fits your hand very comfortably and I love being lazy at times doing the lax laid back, hands at side, not glued together, thanks to separate nunchuk and rest of controller set up. The only thing bad about it (and this can be fixed) is the cord.  It gets in the way at times durring fast, movement based, gameplay.

The wii controller, coupled with the nunchuck is probably the most versatile. I also enjoy it very much.

But as for standard controllers, the 360 one is head and shoulders above the rest. I too like my Nyko AirFlo controller that I have for my PC. ;)