Actually, the guy just hates the xbox 360. http://blogs.ign.com/Greggy-IGN/2008/04/15/86861/#comments
Got a 360 for free. Tried a few games for it. Would have chucked it for only a ps3 if he wouldn't have bought DLC for Rock Band.
But, this obviously means it's better. It's not like the two other people's impressions were basically "Yeah, it's the same thing, but slightly different. Whatever, nice to have it, at least." Oh wait, that pretty much was their response. I think this one guy's idiocy trumps their understated, levelheaded approach.
The dedication you show to any particular console or company is inversely proportional to the number of times you have gotten laid. If you get laid enough, even if you prefer a certain brand, you just don't give enough of a shit to argue about it on the internet.