I hated it, far too often I'd wind up hitting the giant A buttion when I wanted to hit B or X or Y.

agree, I need the c- stick

Yeah, it's better than buying a classic conroller, except the controlls in SMW

Best controller from last gen. No problems with the Z button to me, because is not very used.

I agree. And the fact that the C-stick was mapped to Smash attacks in Melee for the n00bs...

Wow with thumbs that big it must be hard to work your mobile phone.

the controller only works for super smash DS2 is wayyy better

The best controller ever created.

Great controller, IMO. The Z button seems like an afterthought and it's probably the worst aspect of it. The D-pad could have been a bit better, but it's not a big deal, since it's barely used in GCN games. The buttons are fine. A and B are the most commonly used ones and closer to your thumb, A being the most used and thus bigger and at the center. X and Y are not used that often so they are further from the center (A). I think the layout keeps you from confusing the buttons as each one has a different size/feel.

wtf is up with the buttons? the A button is like 4 times as big as anything on the whole controller

I loved the different sizes of the buttons.. triggers were extremly good.. nice *clik* in the end.. The controller felt good in the hand! One of the best controllers ever made..