Still...We have alot of "sugguest a game to me" threads on the 360 forum.

We still have the games you should buy thread, but I think we might scrap it in favor of this.

It follows the same format that we had for the "Most Anticipated RPG" thread. Each person will get 5, and 3 votes. 5 "General Votes" for the best games on the 360, and 3 votes for best of genre..To make this very simple, each vote carries the same weight..Copy and Paste this list, and just add your votes:

Best Xbox 360 Game

Best FPS/TPS

Best Racer  

Best Action Game 

Best Adventure

Best RPG (J and W) 

Best RTS/Strategy Game 

Best "Other" Game

Best Xbox 360 (Console) Exclusive 

Best MultiPlatform Game

Best Fighter Best

XBLA Game

Other rules: You may vote once per month, as new releases can change your mind for top games in genres. If this goes over well (15+ replies in 2 days), I will remove the other thread, and paste this one. We can also add some quick reviews for the top-rated games. If there are any other genres I am forgetting, let me know.

Let me know if you had a different voting  format in mind.

Best Xbox 360 Game - Halo 3

Best FPS/TPS - Halo 3
Best Racer - GRID
Best Action Game - Ninja Gaiden 2
Best Adventure - Castlevania SotN
Best RPG (J and W) - MAss Effect
Best RTS/Strategy Game - Halo Wars when it comes out :)
Best "Other" Game - Viva Pinata
Best Xbox 360 (Console) Exclusive - Halo 3
Best MultiPlatform Game - GTA4


You forgot
Best fighter - Street fighter 2 Turbo (Online)
Best Xbox Live Arcade - Castlevania SoTN

*EDIT - changed my adventure vote

You can have more votes than that...Disoliude.

I'll add fighter, and best XBLA game...How's that?

Best FPS/TPS - COD4
Best Racer - Forza 2
Best Action Game - Ninja Gaiden 2
Best Adventure - ???

Best RPG (J and W) - Lost Odyssey
Best RTS/Strategy Game - I only have Spectral Force 3, so I'll say that.
Best "Other" Game - Viva Pinata
Best Xbox 360 (Console) Exclusive - Halo 3
Best MultiPlatform Game - COD4

Best Fighter - I don't have any for the 360, so I'll say possibly SCIV or SF2 HD Remix.
Best XBLA - Ikaruga

edit: in the OP you put "Best Fighter Best", may want to fix that.

Best Xbox 360 Game - Mass Effect
Best Adventure - Castlevania SotN

Best FPS/TPS - Halo Triple
Best Racer - PGR3
Best Action Game - Ninja Gaiden 2

Best RPG (J and W) - Mass Effect
Best "Other" Game - Viva Pinata
Best Xbox 360 (Console) Exclusive - Mass Effect
Best MultiPlatform Game - COD4

XBLA Game - Geometry Wars

Best Xbox 360 Game - Gears of War
Best FPS/TPS - Gears of War
Best Racer - Forza 2
Best Action Game - Ninja Gaiden 2
Best Adventure - Oblivion
Best RPG (J and W) - Lost Odyssey
Best RTS/Strategy Game - ?
Best "Other" Game - Viva Pinata
Best Xbox 360 (Console) Exclusive - Gears of War
Best MultiPlatform Game - Grand Theft Auto 4
Best Fighter - Dead or Alive 4
XBLA Game - Bomberman Live

Best FPS/TPS - Halo 3
Best Racer - Forza Motorsport 2
Best Action Game - Ninja Gaiden 2
Best Adventure - Dead Rising(?)
Best RPG - Lost Odyssey
Best Strategy - CnC3
Best Other - Viva Pinata
Best Console Exclusive - Gears of War
Best Multiplatform Game - Rock Band
Best Fighter - DOA4
XBLA - Rez HD

I choose Gears for best exclusive even though Halo 3 is the game that I chose for shooter just because it's a new IP for the 360 and think it would appeal to a newer audience.  Some of these will change I imagine soon when games this fall come out.

Interesting, I just ordered my 360 about 1 hour ago, so I might be interested in some of these games as rentals, though I have decided which games I am getting with the system

Best Xbox 360 Game - Halo 3

Best FPS/TPS - Gears of War

Best Racer - Forza Motorsport 2

Best Action Game - Ninja Gaiden 2

Best Adventure - Dunno

Best RPG (J and W) - Mass Effect

Best RTS/Strategy Game - Command and Conquer 3

Best "Other" Game - Viva Pinata

Best Xbox 360 (Console) Exclusive -Halo 3

Best MultiPlatform Game- Rock Band

Best Fighter Best - Virtua Fighter 5

XBLA Game - Rez HD

This thread needs to be restarted, and each genre gets its' own 'user-of-the-year'-type list, except that we don't subtract anything. Also, how will anything ever 'win'? Is there a time limit that we have to vote?

For example:

Best Action Game:

-Gears of War (9)
-Dead Rising (4)
-Call of Duty 4 (12)
-Call of Duty 3 (0)
-Call of Duty 2 (3)
-Perfect Dark 0 (1)
-Mass Effect (6)

etc. (None of those were my vote btw)