CDiablo said: Resistance and/or Bioshock belong there, Bioshock moreso methinks. I actually agree with SMG being one of the most overrated games of all time. GTA 4 and Ocarina of time belong there as well(both very good but overrated.)

Dude, drop your ass and RUN! You can't go around calling Ocarina of Time overrated on a public gaming site without a lynch mob forming after you!

 BTW, Ocarina of time came out in 97, its officially beyond a decade ago ;)

 

Any list like this will differ from person to person. For example I agree SMG is overrated but that not saying it's a bad game. No matter who makes up a list there will be some very high scoring games on the list because it about  being "overrated".

There is no reason to get upset if you happen to find a game you like on someone's overrated list especially if the game got a very high score.

And who is this guy and why do we care what he thinks. Just some loser trying to get attention and we are giving it to him are we not?

Gameplay is nice for once. An objective you can complete. Something to aim for. Fun. Tamagotchi's are no game (and Nintendogs is nothing else.) Sims is a bit more complex but in the end not much else. As far as I have understood Harvest Moon is a "game" where you actually farm. Hello? I may be oldfashioned but I thought gaming was to do something exciting, to do things you cannot do easily in the real world, to escape. Not weeding. In my time we did those things outside in the real world and played games to do something more exciting like shoot aliens, be an adventurer or space pilot. Not manuring sheesh, what the youth has come to today. Really sad.

Gameplay is nice for once. An objective you can complete. Something to aim for. Fun. Tamagotchi's are no game (and Nintendogs is nothing else.) Sims is a bit more complex but in the end not much else. As far as I have understood Harvest Moon is a "game" where you actually farm. Hello? I may be oldfashioned but I thought gaming was to do something exciting, to do things you cannot do easily in the real world, to escape. Not weeding. In my time we did those things outside in the real world and played games to do something more exciting like shoot aliens, be an adventurer or space pilot. Not manuring sheesh, what the youth has come to today. Really sad.

 LOL, I like your style.  Not sure why you would care if a game is over rated or not.  Just a game that someone else likes.  I think all horror movies are over rated(even though they are usually rated bad, but that just goes to show you how much I despise them) because think they are shit movies.  One man's trash is another man's treasure.  Once you realize that, you can get on with your life.