deskpro2k3 said:
Vodacixi said:
Then we should add Wind Waker and Majora's Mask to the conversation. And trust me, that doesn't favour FF VII at all. There is no amount of PSP spin offs or mediocre CGI movies that can compete with three masterpieces of gaming. Especially when we are talking about... well, games.
Not that this hipothetical situation matters, because we are comparing two particular games right here: PS1's clasic FF VII, launched in 1997 and N64's classic TLoZ: Ocarina of Time, launched in 1998. Everything else doesn't matter at all. Movies, remasters, sequels, spin offs... that is irrelevant. If you need external material to get the full experience of a game in order to beat another single game... then maybe your game is flawed to begin with, because it fails to complete itself.
|
Those stories is pretty much forgotten but go ahead and add them to the mix if it makes you feel like it's better. Oh I forgot, those stories still don't compare to FF7, because FF7 story is still impactful even today. So strange for a "flawed" game huh?
|
"Is still impactful even today". Okay: how so? I'm genuinely curious.
Also, we are not talking about just story here. We are talking about games. Which are a lot more than that. And if in order to say that FF VII is better than Ocarina you need to mention tbat it has spin offs and a CGI movie, maybe you are lacking arguments for the actual 1997 game. Which I repeat, is the one we are talking about here.
The whole point of this conversation we are having is to make you understand how silly is to throw external material in the equation when we are comparing two particular games. It makes no sense because what we are talking about is: "I played Ocarina of Time and also Final Fantasy VII. Which one is better?" We are discussing this two games. Not which one got more or better extra media. If you say "FF wins in story, music... and spin offs and movies", then you clearly lack any more arguments than story and music. Because you resort to things external to the game in question.
But even if we resort to external things, Ocarina of Time received two sequels that are considered gaming masterpieces. That alone is enough to bury your cute little PSP spin offs and your CGI movie that will only appeal to fans, but as an actual movie is mediocre at best.
Then again, this last paragraph hardly matters because WE ARE DISCUSSING A N64 AND A PS1 ONE GAME HERE. NOT SPIN OFFS AN MOVIES.
I don't have anything else to say.