I had maintained for years that For Your Eyes Only was the best of the Moore era but recently had been debating whether or not to elevate The Spy Who Loved Me. This rewatch was going to be the deciding factor. How did it turn out? You’ll have to wait (or skip) to the end.
Coming off Moonraker, Bond was brought back down to earth with a Cold War story similar to that of From Russia with Love with as little gadgetry as possible. The mixture of Moore’s more laid back portrayal of Bond and the grittier Bond of the Connery era also reaches its peak here and is probably the best performance of his run. His relationship with Melina is given real time to develop and they don’t even consummate it on screen. Bond shows actual concern over her need for revenge and how it could lead to her own death. This also gives the Bond Girl a separate, independent storyline of her own. She’s involved because she wants to be in order to get justice for her parents. Carole Bouquet emotes a lot without actually speaking (as she was dubbed), her fiery eyes filled with passion and a lust for revenge rather than Bond.
The action scenes are also some of the best of this era. The car chase could be seen as a little silly but having Bond rely on his wits rather than his Lotus to escape the bad guys is more satisfying as it shows his skill rather than just pushing buttons. The ski chase is a great highlight as well and the best sequence of the film. Both are made immeasurably better by the accompanying music fusing an end of the 70s and beginning of the 80s style quite well. Of course, the best moment is Moore kicking the henchmen’s car over the cliff to obtain his own revenge for fallen allies. Moore was apparently put off by these more sadistic scenes but they are the basis of the character going all the way back to Dr. No.
Topol is one of the best allies Bond has had in a while and is a mixture of Kerim Bey and Marc-Ange Draco. A Greek smuggler who wins Bond over with his charm and big personality, Columbo and the villain, Kristatos, have their own adversarial relationship which Bond is pushed into and takes advantage of. Glover is fine as the villain, giving his character enough charisma and menace so he can play both sides. The one glaring mistake is the addition of Bibi Dahl. She adds nothing to the plot and it doesn’t even make sense why she would be there in the finale.
Part of the allure of FYEO is also the tension in seeing how Bond escapes. When he’s cornered on the ski jump without his gun, being keelhauled across coral to become shark bait or dangling precariously off a cliff, this is a Bond who has to work at getting the job done. It’s far from effortless. And while Moore is starting to show his age a bit in these later entries, he’s game to make the scenes as real as possible. He wanted to do some of his own skiing but was refused for insurance purposes. The music helps to further the tension such as the frantic untying of the binds before he and Melina are run down by Kristatos’ boat. It won’t be long before Bond is shooting down dozens of henchmen with little thought so it’s nice to enjoy the actual stakes in films such as this one.
I’ve debated how to rate this for a bit. I’ve settled on 8/10. I was going to give it a 7 because I thought I was being too generous to these films as a whole (and I have been) but I think it deserves an extra point just because I still get that thrill from watching it even after multiple viewings. The story and most of the characters are strong and it was great to see a Bond relying more on his own skills than on gadgets in a smaller stakes story that does not rely on yet another megalomaniac threatening to destroy the world. This is Moore’s best and one of the top films of the franchise.
Current Rankings:
1) On Her Majesty’s Secret Service
2) From Russia with Love
3) Goldfinger
4) For Your Eyes Only
5) The Spy Who Loved Me
6) Thunderball
7) Dr. No
8) Live and Let Die
9) You Only Live Twice
10) The Man with the Golden Gun
11) Moonraker
12) Diamonds are Forever