So how this works is you will rate the movie above you /10 and also say something nice/memorable or bad about that movie.  Since I am the first person I will start out with..   Nightcrawler 2014.

9.5/10 masterpiece.

Sixth Sense (1999).

Also 9.5/10. My favorite horror film, and second favorite Shyamalan film behind Unbreakable.

Edit: forgot my movie. Um... Back to the Future.

6.5/10 Overrated movie.
Mad Max: Fury Road.

Hands down best action film of all time 10/10

Moonlight

9/10 Loved it, really fantastic acting. Mahershala Ali is just amazing. At times the screenplay gets a lil slow for my taste tho.

The Room (2003)

Is that Beavis and Butthead do America 1996?

I've seen it but can't remember any of it 2/10. I must have been very drunk or high at the time. (1996, very likely both)

Moon (2009)

I wanna play but I haven't seen Moon, although I've been interested since I heard about it around 2010. Also someone needs to do the OP. Poor bastard. :)

Moon 10/10 (Nightcrawler was creepy AF Gyllenhal and I'll give it a 6/10 for doing what it did well)

The Fountain

Not a fan of Darren Aronofsky, but The Fountain is an exception, it blew my mind 9.5/10, what a beautiful, haunting movie.
(And when it comes to Nightcrawler, that is at least a 8.5/10).

Full Metal Jacket