shikamaru317 said:
I also see Danaerys fans are angry that she is increasingly being turned into a villain. Have you guys gone back and watched the earlier seasons? I have had severe doubts about Dany ever since season 1. A good ruler needs to show mercy at times, and the concept of mercy has been alien to her throughout the series. She allowed her husband to pour molten metal on her brothers head and burned the witch alive in season 1, locked her friend and the merchant guy in the vault to die in season 2, crucified people, burned the Dothraki leaders alive, wanted to raze King's Landing with her dragons (but was talked out of it by her advisers), executed Sam's father and brother when they refused to bend the knee (against objections from Tyrion). I honestly think there is too much of her father, the Mad King, in her to ever be a good ruler. Jon Snow has always been the only person in the whole show fit to rule in the end, because he is the only one who doesn't want to rule and has shown mercy at several points during the show.
|
Fun trivia. In the fifth book, the Sons of Harpies raped, tortured and killed some of the people Daenerys freed from slavery. Yet, Daenery refrained from harming the noble children she held as hostage, for which she is commended for answering butchery with mercy. In the same dialogue, Daenerys says she's no butcher queen, and would not harm them for murders that were not their doing. Jon Snow, in the same book, executes Janos Slynt for slighting him as commander of the Night's Watch. Janos calls for mercy, but Jon thinks in turn "this door has long been closed". A few chapters later, he watches unblinkingly as Rattleshirt is burned by Stannis and Melissanre in a fire, and he repeatedly calls for mercy from the flames.
Early on the first book, Ned Stark says it was the "madness of mercy" that prompted him to tell Cersei he knew her secret and offer her the chance of escaping, when questioned by Varys as he is imprisoned. So I'm not sure which message we're supposed to take from all of that. Given GRRM loves foreshadowing and all of that, and has openly criticized unexpected twists and plots who lack a logical foundation on preceeding events.
Another fun trivia I've just found: in the same book Tyrion muses that unless one of these long iron scorpion bolts chanced to find an eye, Daenery's dragons would not be brought down by such "toys". And "tickling" dragons with these would only make them angry, and trying would be as useless as to try to quench flames with a spear.
Last edited by haxxiy - on 12 May 2019