Baalzamon said: I have to ask - You indicate you don't consider Youtube videos evidence as you want a primary source. Do you disregard local news, newspapers, etc. as well? The majority of "news" sources do not cite their sources. |
First of all, reputable news organizations should be citing their sources for things which require sources. If the president says something, they don't need to cite the first person who reported on the quote, but if ABC has an anonymous source who says "x", anyone reporting on "x" should be citing ABC.
That said, the reason I don't accept Youtube video's goes beyond citing sources. The type of content you find on Youtube is virtually never "Here are the facts", it is typically "Here is my personal opinion and interpretation of the facts". I am not having an argument with Laura Ingraham, so I don't really care what her opinion is. I also find her to be as intelligent as a bag of potatoes, but that is beside the point. If you post a ten minute video, you are asking me to wade through what is likely to be 9 minutes of babbling and spin around 1 minute of "fact". All I care about is the facts of the case. It is up to the individual making the argument to contextualize those facts and explain how they relate to the argument.
I've said it before, but an argument has three facets:
1) The hypothesis
2) The evidence
3) The explanation of how that evidence proves the hypothesis
What I ask is that an individual actually do the work to create a coherent argument. Simply saying "Biden Bad" and then posting a Youtube video states a hypothesis and then posts video footage of some blowhard doing the rest. I can't take that seriously as an argument and more often than not, it is just a waste of my time. When an individual decides to be lazy and not do the work to formulate an argument, why should I waste my own time trawling through ten minutes of garbage to try to figure out what their point may have been?
While I typically also wouldn't prefer a blog post regarding someone's opinions, at least with a blog post, I can skim through it in a minute or so to figure out if there is anything worth responding to.