You haven't played TLOU and you aren't a fan of GTA V but you're correcting me?  

No, it was better. In the same way TLOU is better than Mario Odyssey. General consensus isn't everything. 

Yes - because all I did was state my opinion. My opinion isn't anything but my opinion. It is better than those two games - to me. That shouldn't even have to be defined. So I don't think it's place as a GOTY winner is so crazy, because it is better than those alternatives to me. And if the GOTY contenders were restricted to just the two aforementioned games, than GOTY awards would be a lot more boring than they already are. 

I could understand if the word "legit" maybe through you off, but that's just internet lingo, not me saying my opinion is all that matters. And you clearly don't have a problem with people stating opinions in a definitive manner considering the person you replied to positively was literally making fun of the idea that 3D World could be compared to those two games in terms of overall quality (from the viewpoint of whoever decides these GOTY awards), and also since your first reply to me just ended in "but still, dude... no." As if that should have all the weight in the world. (Although knowing you that's probably a joke haha, still something to think about if it's serious)

If you read your own replies, but you were changed with Runa and the topic was changed to Skyward Sword, you'd be all over your own replies arguing! I can see it now - "Somthing something, I've never played Skyward Sword but WAGGLE!!! Therefore objectively not as good as Skyrim!" 

Uncharted 2. Mass Effect 2 runner up. Both of those games also feature the best asses on the list. Strictly on quality of ass, Mass Effect wins. And that's saying something given Chloe's presence in Uncharted.

Wow none of these are anywhere near my top 10 videogames. Maybe Uncharted 2?

Lol yea, makes you wonder who is voting for these lists. Bloodborne is the best game I have played in the last 2 decades. I am not saying my taste is the norm but quality is quality, a dumbed down soccer game using go-karts is the last thing that comes to mind when when thinking of quality.

Skyrim is still the best game of that list. Breath of the Wild is fantastic, but it loses steam at around the 100th hour, while I've gone passed 200h with Skyrim.

How did Super Mario 3D World win 2013? lol

-Bioshock Infinite

-TLoU

-GTA V

-Rayman Legends

-Zelda A Link Between Worlds

Huh, how did it win 2013's GOTY?

People would sadly say the same about Rayman Legends (and most likely ALBTW) had it managed to win. Which is a shame ... might be my favorite game from that year. 

Breath of the Wild!

I actually agree with 2013, 3D World was fun, maybe A Link Between Worlds instead but GTA is boring and The Last of Us was.. not good.