So you think PS4 sold above 1,700,000 - 1,850,000. Interesting choice. 

well reasons i think that are 199$ bundle lasted much longer then last year, and spiderman is huge, so why not? 

Not questioning the limited availability of it? Hey if you are right that it sells close to 2 million I will give you your dues. I am still going to call you are pessimistic nature of going super against Nintendo, but I will give you your dues. 

I also used to think so... now I a leaning more towards 1.4M - 1.6M

That could have just been due to better rationing on the stores part making sure they had enough stock available through out the season. 

Sony could have sent out only exactly 1M of that spiderman bundle or less. My guess is 1M. The vanilla console with its own deals would have made up the rest of the sales for the month. And i don't see that being 800k worth of sales either side of that spiderman bundle. 

It was also weird when he recently said he didn't have access to Cyber Monday data.  Like how does that work, is data just given to him on a daily basis?  Then after a few Cyber Monday reports came out he then was able to dig some data up.  Another weird thing was when he said October data was weird and h e couldnt tell who won before NPD.  

Don't know if he is legit or not but nothing he says is very specific or proof he has some type of insider data.  

Too bad Sony didnt have the bandwidth to keep that $200 spiderman bundle in stock, would have been HUGE #'s.

yea i feel the same way he covers all his angles, and is protected by resetera like a god. ps4 won by april, by nearly 100% irrc yet he never mentioned ps4 taking the month easily, october was also huge win by around 30% yet not mention who wins or ps4 taking the month easily, a lot of things he does don't add up, hopefully these numbers are true and people realize he's probably not legit. I understand when things are close his data not getting things right, but when there is a huge lead his data should show other wise his data is useless.

Hardly they would lied, but it wouldn't be first time their PR is not most accurate.

What is very possible is that with "more than 8.2m" numbers gave us numbers until October with this "5 day period sales", so without other November numbers. And that would actually make sense, because it expected that Switch in that period sold around 800-900k (because thats more than Wii best week and perfectly fit with those "more than 8.2m" sold units).

Also, this one of latests Benji posts:

-I think estimating anywhere from 1.1 million - 1.5 million for Switch in November is realistic. I know that's a big range but given the PR (outside the weird LTD figure) it seem highly unlikely it's either below or above that figure

LTD on US sales from nintendo  hasn't been wrong in over a decade last years article  gave us accurate NPD figures before they came out.

https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20180104005222/en/Nintendo-Switch-Fastest-Selling-Home-Video-Game-System 

I'm looking forward to NPD which will reflect these numbers posted by nintendo. don't really care for benji, after this hopefully everyone see's that he's not legit.

OK the suggestion that PS4 is down - is that YOY or November ?

Wasn't it already tracking below last year.. and if so what was the difference between them before November. It's possible that if YOY it was down a couple hundred thousand that it could still beat last Novembers numbers... just trying to get a grasp of it.

As for Switch I don't see it being as close as benji suggests. I find that he usually speaks after someone else has already said something and uses his limited data and anecdotal evidence. But still good to get some info.