By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - EDGE #326 review scores

tripenfall on 19 November 2018
ZODIARKrebirth said:
CaptainExplosion said:

Why do I have a feeling they only give 10s to Rockstar developed games?

what games got a 10 from edge in the last years?
Super Mario 64[23] Nintendo 64 E035 1996
Gran Turismo[24] PlayStation E055 1998
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time[25] Nintendo 64 E066 1998
Halo: Combat Evolved[26] Xbox E105 2001
Half-Life 2[27] Windows E143 2004
Halo 3[28] Xbox 360 E181 2007
The Orange Box[29] Windows, Xbox 360 E182 2007
Super Mario Galaxy[30] Wii E183 2007
Grand Theft Auto IV[31] PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 E189 2008
LittleBigPlanet[32] PlayStation 3 E195 2008
Bayonetta[33] Xbox 360 E209 2009
Super Mario Galaxy 2[34] Wii E215 2010
Rock Band 3[35] PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 E222 2010
The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword[36] Wii E234 2011
The Last of Us[37] PlayStation 3 E255 2013
Grand Theft Auto V[38] PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 E259 2013
Bayonetta 2[39] Wii U E272 2014
Bloodborne PlayStation 4 E279 2015
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Nintendo Switch, Wii U E304 2017
Super Mario Odyssey[40] Nintendo Switch E312 2017 


Around the Network
ZODIARKrebirth on 19 November 2018
pokoko said:
ZODIARKrebirth said:

what games got a 10 from edge in the last years?

I can tell you that GTA IV and GTA V both got 10s.  In the case of GTA IV, there was controversy because some people thought the review didn't point to a "10".  Honestly, I can't believe anyone gave GTA IV a 10, much less a publication where earning a 10 is supposed to be a rare event.  RDR1 got a 9, which is kind of amusing to me, as EDGE is supposedly all about gameplay and RDR1 was mediocre at best in that regard.

Personally, I would have been shocked if RDR2 didn't get a 10 from EDGE and I mean that in all seriousness.

so it seems we will not see a 10 review from edge a long time