By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Can Super Smash Ultimate Be the Highest Rated Game of the Gen? (>Botw/GoW/SMO/RDR2)

It is possible, but low to mid 90's seems more likely. There's no way it will be lower than that though.


Btw, fixed your thread title:

Can Super Smash Ultimate Be the Highest Rated Game of the Gen? (>Botw/SMO/RDR2)



Around the Network

I think it will be a series high, but not as high as Zelda, mario or red dead. 94-95 seems likely. Anyone saying below 90 is guaranteed to be wrong.



It's not going to beat BotW. It may equal it, but it's not going to beat it.



You know it deserves the GOTY.

Come join The 2018 Obscure Game Monthly Review Thread.

I really think you need an engaging single-player campaign to score that highly these days.

I expect Smash to land around 92-94.



tbone51 said:

Thats true but i think ssbu looking hugely improved compared to ssb4 almost like smo was to sm3dw.

So can we assume your prediction is that it will?

Because you haven't given one, which is a bit much!



Around the Network

No chance, I agree with low 90’s; maybe 93. Which is still amazing, if it matters much.



Highly unlikely. High 80s to low 90s (88-93) would be my guess.



It's not game changing like Mario Odyssey or BotW, nor is it a single player cinematic game like RDR2 and GoW. However, it should be higher than 92 since it's clearly looking to be better than its predecessor.



Barkley said:
tbone51 said:

Thats true but i think ssbu looking hugely improved compared to ssb4 almost like smo was to sm3dw.

So can we assume your prediction is that it will?

Because you haven't given one, which is a bit much!

Oh i see lol. I think realistically itll be about 94 or 95 (which is still very high). I just think if there is a game that can do a 97/98 it would be smash ultimate



tbone51 said:

Oh i see lol. I think realistically itll be about 94 or 95 (which is still very high). I just think if there is a game that can do a 97/98 it would be smash ultimate

I agree, if I had to pick a single number I'd probably say 93. But 91-95 sounds about right to me.