By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Politics Discussion - Was Hitler a Socialist?

Chris Hu said:
collint0101 said:

The word privatization was literally invented to describe Nazi economic policies. Then people still try to say they weren't capitalist 

Yeap, the Nazi's actually privatized more things in Germany then any other country during the same time period so his statement is 100% false.

when will you stop with these lies?

" German business increasingly turned to Nazism as offering a way out of the situation, by promising a state-driven economy that would support, rather than attack, existing business interests.[35] By January 1933, the Nazi Party had secured the support of important sectors of German industry, mainly among the steel and coal producers, the insurance business and the chemical industry.[36]

Large segments of the Nazi Party, particularly among the members of the Sturmabteilung (SA), were committed to the party's official socialist, revolutionary and anti-capitalist positions and expected both a social and an economic revolution when the party gained power in 1933."

 

" Hitler actively sought to gain the support of business leaders by arguing that private enterprise is incompatible with democracy."

 

 "In addition, the Nazis privatised public properties and public services, but at the same time they increased economic state control through regulations."

 

for the hundredth time, a business is not private if its controlled by the state

Last edited by o_O.Q - on 08 October 2018

Around the Network
o_O.Q said:

mr wayne i've recently seen you claiming that equality of opportunity must lead to equality of outcomes over time...


so with that being said i'm thinking that i probably am not going to be able to have a rational conversation with you on this topic
but regardless hitler's policies by the majority were socialist policies:

free healhcare, state funded education, state funded child care, jobs for all(initially), government control over businesses etc etc etc

 

capitalism, the antithesis to socialism is about private ownership over the means of production which was not allowed since as i have mentioned the nazis controlled businesses in their regime

No they did not more businesses where privatized in Nazi Germany then in any other country during the same time.



Chris Hu said:
o_O.Q said:

mr wayne i've recently seen you claiming that equality of opportunity must lead to equality of outcomes over time...


so with that being said i'm thinking that i probably am not going to be able to have a rational conversation with you on this topic
but regardless hitler's policies by the majority were socialist policies:

free healhcare, state funded education, state funded child care, jobs for all(initially), government control over businesses etc etc etc

 

capitalism, the antithesis to socialism is about private ownership over the means of production which was not allowed since as i have mentioned the nazis controlled businesses in their regime

No they did not more businesses where privatized in Nazi Germany then in any other country during the same time.

when will you stop with these lies?

" German business increasingly turned to Nazism as offering a way out of the situation, by promising a state-driven economy that would support, rather than attack, existing business interests.[35] By January 1933, the Nazi Party had secured the support of important sectors of German industry, mainly among the steel and coal producers, the insurance business and the chemical industry.[36]

Large segments of the Nazi Party, particularly among the members of the Sturmabteilung (SA), were committed to the party's official socialist, revolutionary and anti-capitalist positions and expected both a social and an economic revolution when the party gained power in 1933."

 

Hitler actively sought to gain the support of business leaders by arguing that private enterprise is incompatible with democracy."

 

 "In addition, the Nazis privatised public properties and public services, but at the same time they increased economic state control through regulations."

 

for the hundredth time, a business is not private if its controlled by the state



o_O.Q said:
Chris Hu said:

Yeap, the Nazi's actually privatized more things in Germany then any other country during the same time period so his statement is 100% false.

when will you stop with these lies?

" German business increasingly turned to Nazism as offering a way out of the situation, by promising a state-driven economy that would support, rather than attack, existing business interests.[35] By January 1933, the Nazi Party had secured the support of important sectors of German industry, mainly among the steel and coal producers, the insurance business and the chemical industry.[36]

Large segments of the Nazi Party, particularly among the members of the Sturmabteilung (SA), were committed to the party's official socialist, revolutionary and anti-capitalist positions and expected both a social and an economic revolution when the party gained power in 1933."

 

" Hitler actively sought to gain the support of business leaders by arguing that private enterprise is incompatible with democracy."

 

for the hundredth time, a business is not private if its controlled by the state

Those are not lies actually read the article that I linked to you weeks ago about how the Nazi's privatized more business in Germany then any other country in the world during the same time period.  Your lying to yourself if you truly think the Nazi's where socialist. 



o_O.Q said:
Chris Hu said:

No they did not more businesses where privatized in Nazi Germany then in any other country during the same time.

when will you stop with these lies?

" German business increasingly turned to Nazism as offering a way out of the situation, by promising a state-driven economy that would support, rather than attack, existing business interests.[35] By January 1933, the Nazi Party had secured the support of important sectors of German industry, mainly among the steel and coal producers, the insurance business and the chemical industry.[36]

Large segments of the Nazi Party, particularly among the members of the Sturmabteilung (SA), were committed to the party's official socialist, revolutionary and anti-capitalist positions and expected both a social and an economic revolution when the party gained power in 1933."

 

Hitler actively sought to gain the support of business leaders by arguing that private enterprise is incompatible with democracy."

 

 "In addition, the Nazis privatised public properties and public services, but at the same time they increased economic state control through regulations."

 

for the hundredth time, a business is not private if its controlled by the state

For the thousands time actually read the articles that I posted earlier.



Around the Network

Hitler was a man that used any tools he had at the time at his disposal to convince people to do what he wanted. He would have been a socialist, communist, democrat or republican if it helped his cause lol



 

 

Chris Hu said:
o_O.Q said:

when will you stop with these lies?

" German business increasingly turned to Nazism as offering a way out of the situation, by promising a state-driven economy that would support, rather than attack, existing business interests.[35] By January 1933, the Nazi Party had secured the support of important sectors of German industry, mainly among the steel and coal producers, the insurance business and the chemical industry.[36]

Large segments of the Nazi Party, particularly among the members of the Sturmabteilung (SA), were committed to the party's official socialist, revolutionary and anti-capitalist positions and expected both a social and an economic revolution when the party gained power in 1933."

 

" Hitler actively sought to gain the support of business leaders by arguing that private enterprise is incompatible with democracy."

 

for the hundredth time, a business is not private if its controlled by the state

Those are not lies actually read the article that I linked to you weeks ago about how the Nazi's privatized more business in Germany then any other country in the world during the same time period.  Your lying to yourself if you truly think the Nazi's where socialist. 

to reiterate

"by arguing that private enterprise is incompatible with democracy."

 "they increased economic state control through regulations."

tell me what you understand from these lines

the articles you posted give the same message



o_O.Q said:
Chris Hu said:

Those are not lies actually read the article that I linked to you weeks ago about how the Nazi's privatized more business in Germany then any other country in the world during the same time period.  Your lying to yourself if you truly think the Nazi's where socialist. 

to reiterate

"by arguing that private enterprise is incompatible with democracy."

 "they increased economic state control through regulations."

tell me what you understand from these lines

the articles you posted give the same message

Did you actually read the whole thing it also proofs the undeniable fact that the Nazi's privatized more businesses in Germany then any other country during the same period of time.  Again actually read the WHOLE article and then come back at me Hoss.



Chris Hu said:
o_O.Q said:

to reiterate

"by arguing that private enterprise is incompatible with democracy."

 "they increased economic state control through regulations."

tell me what you understand from these lines

the articles you posted give the same message

Did you actually read the whole thing it also proofs the undeniable fact that the Nazi's privatized more businesses in Germany then any other country during the same period of time.  Again actually read the WHOLE article and then come back at me Hoss.

if i give you a car and i tell you that its yours as long as you don't drive it out of the street that its parked on is it yours? that sounds silly right? so why are you arguing essentially the same thing when it comes to business in germany?

the businesses in germany were another arm of the government since the government controlled and directed them



o_O.Q said:
Chris Hu said:

Did you actually read the whole thing it also proofs the undeniable fact that the Nazi's privatized more businesses in Germany then any other country during the same period of time.  Again actually read the WHOLE article and then come back at me Hoss.

if i give you a car and i tell you that its yours as long as you don't drive it out of the street that its parked on is it yours? that sounds silly right? so why are you arguing essentially the same thing when it comes to business in germany?

the businesses in germany were another arm of the government since the government controlled and directed them

No they did not.  Again the Nazi's privatized more businesses in Germany then any other country in the world during the same period of time.  Apparently you don't understand what privatization means so get back at me when you pass a class of basic economics 101.