TranceformerFX said: So what you're saying is that it's acceptable for Scarlet Johansen to play Major Kusanagi because were not constantly reminded that she's Japanese in the original cartoon/source material? I lol'd because your comment came off as silly to me. Also, your reply makes no sense in context to your original comment. |
You know, restructuring arguments to sound as ridiculous as possible is not an honest way to debate. Whether you "lol'd" or not is of no importance to me, if you're not going to be respectable there is nothing to talk about here.
The fact is, most people who are actually Japanese and live in Japan didn't care. The director of the original movie, which is the part of the GiTS franchise being adapted, didn't care that Scarlet was a white person.
But the biggest point of all, which you'll probably restructure to sound as ridiculous as possible, is that the race of the character was never important to the original movie. Yes, no matter what you try to do to downplay this point, for the most part it's the characters that rely on their race where the actor's race is important to get right. Ghost in the Shell, at least the 1995 anime, is not an example of that. In fact, as far as I know, there is more discussion on race in the Scarlet movie then there is in the actual anime.
By the way, you should tell Japanese people they can't make Fullmetal Alchemist live action movies anymore, since the main characters are of European descent but are played by a Japanese cast.