Quantcast
God of War review thread - Meta: 94 OC: 95

Forums - Sony Discussion - God of War review thread - Meta: 94 OC: 95

Errorist76 said:
Hynad said:

Some publications are weighted more on metacritics, just because.

If that's true that's ridiculous and will make me stop visiting that site.

It's on their website.

 

http://www.metacritic.com/about-metascores

"WHY THE TERM “WEIGHTED AVERAGE” MATTERS

Metascore is a weighted average in that we assign more importance, or weight, to some critics and publications than others, based on their quality and overall stature" .

 

 

That's why opencritic is coming up .



Around the Network

http://n4g.com/channel/god-of-war/reviews?load=3

Its a 96 technically for N4G's cumulative reviews 142 to be exact, checked out a lot of a few of these sites, their reviews are very well written shame that aren't on Metacritic considering the other garbage that's on there.



Just seen the hidden ending. Omg!!!

Bring on god of war 2. Holy shit, the hype is real!!!!!



BraLoD said:
It barely survived EDGE score in the 95
Now is wait for Gamecritics...
I think the game still can get 4 more perfect scores, hope it's enough.
EDGE sure weights a lot.

Wteff? It dropped THIRTEEN places from that 80! How the hell weighted is Edge? Every two 100s increased its placing by 2-3, so I cant believe an 80 dropped it so significantly. Unless the majority of remaining reviews are 100s, I see no way for it to maintain its 95 after the impending 60-70 scores from QtT and GameCritics. 



John2290 said:
GOWTLOZ said:

This^

Ahem you two.a Horizon just last year. Ahem.

Horizon isn't like a Naughty Dog game not a bit.



Around the Network
pitzy272 said:
BraLoD said:
It barely survived EDGE score in the 95
Now is wait for Gamecritics...
I think the game still can get 4 more perfect scores, hope it's enough.
EDGE sure weights a lot.

Wteff? It dropped THIRTEEN places from that 80! How the hell weighted is Edge? Every two 100s increased its placing by 2-3, so I cant believe an 80 dropped it so significantly. Unless the majority of remaining reviews are 100s, I see no way for it to maintain its 95 after the impending 60-70 scores from QtT and GameCritics. 

God of War is at the very bottom of the 95s on MC, so yeah, it's close to being a 94, but there have been so many reviews at this point that it's score is pretty well set where it's at. And what do you mean by impending 60 - 70 scores?

Where do you think God of War deserves to be on the list of the greatest games of all time? Do you think a 95 is about right?

I think many people are blinded by the hype right now, and just want to see a game perform very well because it's fun and exciting to be living in a time where something monumental is happening. But the real winners are us gamers who get to enjoy awesome games by awesome developers, amirite?

I'm enjoying God of War immensely, but damn I wish I spent far less time in that damn canoe. As a completionist who likes to explore every nook and cranny at the earliest opportunity, this game can be very tedious.



RaptorChrist said:
pitzy272 said:

Wteff? It dropped THIRTEEN places from that 80! How the hell weighted is Edge? Every two 100s increased its placing by 2-3, so I cant believe an 80 dropped it so significantly. Unless the majority of remaining reviews are 100s, I see no way for it to maintain its 95 after the impending 60-70 scores from QtT and GameCritics. 

God of War is at the very bottom of the 95s on MC, so yeah, it's close to being a 94, but there have been so many reviews at this point that it's score is pretty well set where it's at. And what do you mean by impending 60 - 70 scores?

Where do you think God of War deserves to be on the list of the greatest games of all time? Do you think a 95 is about right?

I think many people are blinded by the hype right now, and just want to see a game perform very well because it's fun and exciting to be living in a time where something monumental is happening. But the real winners are us gamers who get to enjoy awesome games by awesome developers, amirite?

I'm enjoying God of War immensely, but damn I wish I spent far less time in that damn canoe. As a completionist who likes to explore every nook and cranny at the earliest opportunity, this game can be very tedious.

You play it tediously. Not every nook and cranny visible to you can be explored. Its best to do all that after the end game and do it sparingly in the story. Its not Super Mario Odyssey, you don't have to collect all items.

Its deserving of 100 on 100. The combat is incredibly deep and rewarding, it feels good, their are just the right kind of difficulties for all gamers, the story and characters are amazing, voice acting is the best in any game I've played, the exploration reminds me of Batman: Arkham game which is a very high praise and the graphics are the best on a game I've played as a PC, PS4 and Switch gamer. Its just blew me away, I'm a fan of God of War but I had tempered expectations for this one because of the new way they do stuff, I kept my hype low expecting it to not be as good as the other God of War games. I was wrong. This is the best God of War game, the best Game of this generation and very high on my list of best games ever made.



RaptorChrist said:
pitzy272 said:

Wteff? It dropped THIRTEEN places from that 80! How the hell weighted is Edge? Every two 100s increased its placing by 2-3, so I cant believe an 80 dropped it so significantly. Unless the majority of remaining reviews are 100s, I see no way for it to maintain its 95 after the impending 60-70 scores from QtT and GameCritics. 

God of War is at the very bottom of the 95s on MC, so yeah, it's close to being a 94, but there have been so many reviews at this point that it's score is pretty well set where it's at. And what do you mean by impending 60 - 70 scores?

Where do you think God of War deserves to be on the list of the greatest games of all time? Do you think a 95 is about right?

I think many people are blinded by the hype right now, and just want to see a game perform very well because it's fun and exciting to be living in a time where something monumental is happening. But the real winners are us gamers who get to enjoy awesome games by awesome developers, amirite?

I'm enjoying God of War immensely, but damn I wish I spent far less time in that damn canoe. As a completionist who likes to explore every nook and cranny at the earliest opportunity, this game can be very tedious.

Based on history for those sites for scores they give ps4 exclusives, 60-70 scores are very likely for each of them. And GameCritics apparently came out and said their score will be lower than any other score. They’re both blatant trolls. Some sample scores from GameCritics and QtT, respectively:  Uncharted 4: 50 and no score (vs. 93 MC); Horizon 65 and 60 (vs. 89 MC); Bloodborne:  70 and no score (vs. 92 MC); TLoU:  80 and 60 (vs. 95 MC). The guy from QtT reviewed HZD like 3 months late, and he didn’t even realize GoW was coming out until release day or after. Seriously no idea how he’s accepted by Metacritic.  

So far I’m pretty enamored with GoW. Think I’m about 2/3 through. It’s not perfect, including the amt of time spent in the boat lol, but it’s so freaking good in so many ways. So damn epic; combat fantastic (esp when I became better with combos and the controls); story is sweet and has me really interested; acting is almost perfect (just Freya seems a little off); visuals are incredible; music great; etc. When I’m not playing it, I’m thinking about it and can’t wait to play again. So as of right now, I think a 95 MC is absolutely deserved. The game is just so well done and polished.



GOWTLOZ said:
RaptorChrist said:

God of War is at the very bottom of the 95s on MC, so yeah, it's close to being a 94, but there have been so many reviews at this point that it's score is pretty well set where it's at. And what do you mean by impending 60 - 70 scores?

Where do you think God of War deserves to be on the list of the greatest games of all time? Do you think a 95 is about right?

I think many people are blinded by the hype right now, and just want to see a game perform very well because it's fun and exciting to be living in a time where something monumental is happening. But the real winners are us gamers who get to enjoy awesome games by awesome developers, amirite?

I'm enjoying God of War immensely, but damn I wish I spent far less time in that damn canoe. As a completionist who likes to explore every nook and cranny at the earliest opportunity, this game can be very tedious.

You play it tediously. Not every nook and cranny visible to you can be explored. Its best to do all that after the end game and do it sparingly in the story. Its not Super Mario Odyssey, you don't have to collect all items.

Its deserving of 100 on 100. The combat is incredibly deep and rewarding, it feels good, their are just the right kind of difficulties for all gamers, the story and characters are amazing, voice acting is the best in any game I've played, the exploration reminds me of Batman: Arkham game which is a very high praise and the graphics are the best on a game I've played as a PC, PS4 and Switch gamer. Its just blew me away, I'm a fan of God of War but I had tempered expectations for this one because of the new way they do stuff, I kept my hype low expecting it to not be as good as the other God of War games. I was wrong. This is the best God of War game, the best Game of this generation and very high on my list of best games ever made.

That's part of the problem, though. How could I have known that it's best to wait until the end game to do that stuff? Up until reading this comment I've been under the impression that there are missables in the game, based on the fact that the water level changes, which affects areas you can explore. Usually after beating a game, I move on to another game, so I try and complete all side content before the main quest for that reason. As a result, I have actually never beaten games like Skyrim or Fallout, despite putting in hundreds of hours on the former.

God of War is an amazing game, no doubt about it, but in the interest of debate, I'd like to challenge you on a few points that I disagree with.

The devs created a fantastic, immersive experience, possibly the best ever done. I'm maybe two-thirds of the way through the game  (just found out that Freya was a God after climbing the mountain), so I can't comment on the story, but so far it's compelling enough, but not amazing. The voice acting is top notch, and the environments are freaking "holy crap" amazing. So much detail in the environments, it blows me away. I play with a Pro on performance mode as I don't have a 4K TV, so I get a smooth 45 FPS maybe (estimating based on what it feels like). I love the idea of there being a single camera that takes you through the whole game. They didn't even break it for loading screens, and instead transport you to a realm between realms, of sorts. I love this.

As I said before, I haven't beaten the game yet, but based on what I've experienced so far, I can't imagine there being much replay value. I'm curious if you agree with this or not, but I'm thinking that this is a game meant to be played through once, and then put down, and returned to maybe a few years later after you get another desire to play.

But here's why I personally don't think it's on par with the best games of all time. It may seem like I'm grasping for straws, because I partially am. I love this game, and I love showing up for work in the morning to talk with my co-workers about how far we got, and how awesome it is, but...

Because the game is designed in such a "narrative" way, the gameplay is limited: There are many occasions where your character is prevented from using weapons and slowed down to a max speed of walking while characters interact with each other. I'm pretty sure there isn't a way to skip these cutscenes, but even if there were, the point is that it interrupts the pacing.

Animations are too slow: When thoroughly exploring an area, navigating around can be painstakingly tedious at times. They do a good job of creating shortcuts, but the developers focused far more on immersion than quality of life.

The canoe: I have probably spent 2 or 3 hours in the canoe at this point, driving clockwise around the Isle of Nine to stop at every island, each time I get a new upgrade, just to make sure I didn't miss anything.

In summary, the game is epic and impressive. I'm a programmer by profession, and I can appreciate the work the devs put into this game. This game breaths pure talent, and was well-directed, all good stuff, but I'm not having *as much fun* with this game as I did with Zelda or Mario, or many other games.

As a piece of art, however, it's amazing.





 

The PS5 Exists.