Not even close. Uncharted was hyped since day one (PS4’s launch) and was expected to be this generation’s first looker. It also got universal praise. GoW on the other hand received mixed feelings and is coming much later in the cycle.
Every single comment about it from review outlets up until now has been extremely positive.
If you are talking about people posting here, I can say I remember that for Uncharted 4 as well.
A user that now has its doubts about GoW was posing with a Uncharted 4 gif from a bug found on its first gameplay on its signature and trying to bring the hype down and mock it.
A user here said Uncharted 4 animations looked wonky when they were in the absolute top of the industry.
And a lot of people saying Naughty Dog keep making corridor like games so it can look good, that the game had downgrades all the time, and all that stuff.
I agree that we see more genuine doubts about GoW because it has gone for a massive change, but we have not seem a single mixed feeling about people that played it up until now.