By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Movies & TV - Is Rey from Star Wars a Mary Sue?

Yes.

She's a good fighter, she's a good mechanic, she can understand droid, she can pilot the Falcon and knows it better than Han for f***'s sake, she can use the force and overcomes Kylo Ren's mind powers for f***'s sake. She's a good shot, Han likes her, Leia likes her, Finn likes her, BB8 likes her, even Kylo f***ing Ren starts to like her and she's trusted with a mission to find Luke after barely getting to know the rebellion or whatever they're called.

Poe needs rescue from the empire or whatever it's called and Finn rescues him. Finn needs rescue from tentacles and Rey rescues him. Rey needs rescue from capture and she rescues herself.

The most I can say is she's momentarily disabled by being thrown at a tree by Kylo Ren only to get back up and beat Kylo Ren in a laser sword battle...

 

I can't see how she's not a Mary Sue.

 

On a side note, why does Rey give a s*** about the conflict between the rebellion and the empire? What's her motivation and what's stopping her from just going back to... desert planet... and waiting for her parents like before? She sort of just meanders through the plot if memory serves.

Last edited by KLAMarine - on 13 January 2018

Around the Network

She definitely is. The character could have been better written and made sense within the SW universe, she would have been well received.



RolStoppable said:
No, she looks more like a man.

Is she a Gary Stu?

mZuzek said:
So we not only can't stop talking about Star Wars, now we need to make a whole thread to have another pointless argument about something that clearly has only one answer.

We're really good at wasting time.

Aeolus451 said:
She definitely is. The character could have been better written and made sense within the SW universe, she would have been well received.

This latest trilogy seems f***ed. Kylo needs to kill Rey to ascend to ultimate darkness status or Rey needs to turn to the darkness.

That's the only way I can see this trilogy's current trajectory rectifying itself in an interesting way.



KLAMarine said:
RolStoppable said:
No, she looks more like a man.

Is she a Gary Stu?

mZuzek said:
So we not only can't stop talking about Star Wars, now we need to make a whole thread to have another pointless argument about something that clearly has only one answer.

We're really good at wasting time.

Aeolus451 said:
She definitely is. The character could have been better written and made sense within the SW universe, she would have been well received.

This latest trilogy seems f***ed. Kylo needs to kill Rey to ascend to ultimate darkness status or Rey needs to turn to the darkness.

That's the only way I can see this trilogy's current trajectory rectifying itself in an interesting way.

It's owned by disney. I wouldn't be surprised if one of their hallmark characters showed up to save the day.



RolStoppable said:
No, she looks more like a man.

That's one good looking guy.



Around the Network
mZuzek said:
So we not only can't stop talking about Star Wars, now we need to make a whole thread to have another pointless argument about something that clearly has only one answer.

Sorry, what answer would that be by the way?



I think the problem with Rey stems from a lack of real character, as well as true obstacles. I mean, obviously the force enables certain people who are "force sensitive" (since I guess we're tossing the concept of the Jedi out the window now), so of course she's gonna tear shit up. But I think the issue with her is we don't really see her undergo the hero's journey of overcoming real weaknesses, obstacles, conflict (unless you count her brief infatuation w/ Kylo and trying to turn him for some reason), and thus she just feels very wooden to me.

It also almost feels as if Disney wanted to make her as "neutral" and without a real personality as possible so that people can place themselves in her shoes and feel like they're her, but that's not what making a good, interesting protagonist is about IMO, it's about relating to them on a personal level. I just don't really get that sense with Rey. 

Whether you interpret that as being "Mary Sue" is up to you to decide because the definition seems somewhat fluid and relative, but all I know is that's the way I feel about her character.



 

"We hold these truths to be self-evident - all men and women created by the, go-you know.. you know the thing!" - Joe Biden

DarthMetalliCube said:

I think the problem with Rey stems from a lack of real character, as well as true obstacles. I mean, obviously the force enables certain people who are "force sensitive" (since I guess we're tossing the concept of the Jedi out the window now), so of course she's gonna tear shit up. But I think the issue with her is we don't really see her undergo the hero's journey of overcoming real weaknesses, obstacles, conflict (unless you count her brief infatuation w/ Kylo and trying to turn him for some reason), and thus she just feels very wooden to me.

It also almost feels as if Disney wanted to make her as "neutral" and without a real personality as possible so that people can place themselves in her shoes and feel like they're her, but that's not what making a good, interesting protagonist is about IMO, it's about relating to them on a personal level. I just don't really get that sense with Rey. 

Whether you interpret that as being "Mary Sue" is up to you to decide because the definition seems somewhat fluid and relative, but all I know is that's the way I feel about her character.

Not only is she overly capable, there's not enough quiet moments with her. Luke had plenty of them in ANH and we the audience get to know him. Rey's mostly just running from one noisy battle to the next and getting upgrades handed to her along the way.



mZuzek said:
KLAMarine said:

Sorry, what answer would that be by the way?

Yes, of course. Incredibly fruitless to debate this.

Not really. There's still people who disagree with what she is. They just say anything at the moment. Even the actress who plays as rey doesn't believe that rey is a sue. It deserves discussion. 😉



I mean, she's basically the girl version of the MC in Sword Art Online, who most people seem to agree is a Mary Sue (or Gary Stu or Marty Sue or whatever). I don't really see how she wouldn't be. Sure she has a background that makes her that way, but she's also a fictional character that's given that background for a reason. Her story was easily the weakest part of the last movie I watched, and I could practically see a giant Bugs Bunny hand coming down with an eraser to get rid of any potential struggle she might have to deal with.

That being said, I haven't seen the new Star War, so maybe she's been given more actual struggles or character development, but she certainly fits the definition in the last one I watched.



NNID: Zephyr25 / PSN: Zephyr--25 / Switch: SW-4450-3680-7334