Mr Puggsly said:
Halo 5 has better visuals than it gets credit for, I think the art direction was more of the problem and the effects were too ambitious for the hardware.
|
Halo 5's graphics are absolutely terrible.
The Art was the saving grace in my opinion, but even that had room for improvement in a multitude of areas.
Mr Puggsly said:
I mean Halo 5's lighting and performance is ahead of basically any other FPS on the console, at least more ambitious than the average 60 fps game. Doom and Battlefield 1 kinda look bland in some areas compared to Halo 5, but all of these games strengths and weaknesses in various places. Halo 5 being the only game that actually maintains 60 fps.
|
Doom and Battlefield 1 have far more effects happening on screen.
Doom is a massive step up in regards to particles and texturing.. And Battlefield 1's draw distance is significantly larger than Halo 5's.
Halo 5 being "60fps" though is a little disingenuous, many texture and sprite animations are only a paltry 10-15fps which look downright jarring... So if it couldn't hit and maintain 60fps with those cut corners, then it would truly be terrible.
Even the enhanced version of the game on Xbox One X still suffers from short object and shadow draw distance.
Mr Puggsly said:
I think they could have made good on Halo 5's lacking campaign by simply making another ODST or Reach esque campaign using that engine. Because the gameplay in Halo 5 feels great, the campaign just left people wanting more. Never happened though, wasted potential.
|
Halo 5's campaign left allot to be desired, but I think the biggest gripe people had was how the campaign deviated from the advertising campaign and how it ended on a cliff hanger.
I would assume 343i would have learned from that for Halo 6... Halo 4's campaign was actually fairly decent, probably the best aspect of that particular release. - Not Halo 3 levels of standard, but great either way.
adisababa said: I have faith in the Xbox One being a viable platform, it's still successful and a very sustainable platform perfectly adequate to play all the popular games this gen. 2018 will be a great year in terms of first-party games for the Xbox, Sea of Thieves, State of Decay 2, Crackdown 3, Ashen, The Last Night and Forza Horizon 4 are all interesting games that do have the potential to be great if done right. Can't wait for what they have to offer, especially the new Fable and Halo 6. |
I am taking a wait and see approach.
Crackdown 3 has already taken a heap of criticism for it's visual presentation.
Sea of Thieves could be hit or miss (I am hoping it's amazing) as it's a RARE game.
And they are all on PC anyway...
The Xbox One *is* a viable platform, profits are being made.
Also keen to see how a Fable looks on current gen hardware, Fable 1 and 2 were some of my favorite games.
Mr Puggsly said:
I don't know how Xbox can appeal to more people in other countries, but I'm simply saying if they can keep doing about 8 million annually they're in a good place.
I also believe putting Xbox games on PC is good idea because many gamers are not on consoles, including regions Xbox consoles are not popular. So if MS can't get them to buy the console, they can find additional sales on PC.
|
They need some must-have exclusive games... Something new, unique and different. Something like the sadly cancelled Scalebound.
Microsoft convinced me to buy the original Xbox with exclusives and that continued on with the 360.
If Microsoft wishes to appeal to Asian markets... They could simply appeal to Blizzard to make an exclusive AAA Xbox One game, then watch console sales pick up in those markets.
Mr Puggsly said:
The initial disaster of X1 wasn't really that bad. They fixed the major issues prior to launch, the Kinect was removed to lower the price, and MS never made significant price cuts to stay competitive. So even though MS has a lot of money, they didn't do a lot to undercut PS4. Frankly, I don't believe MS was interested in losing money on Xbox. Regardless, the console has thrived fairly well, its a very relevant platform, and Xbox software is now used to prop up Windows Store.
|
Sadly, Microsoft still has to appeal to shareholders, they can't just endlessly throw dollar bills at a problem, they do have limits.
And you are correct, Microsoft did repair the largest issues prior to launch, the DRM, Kinect and Higher Price. - But... They still had less power, ResolutionGate was a real issue being pushed by various outlets.
Snoopy said:
Despite Microsoft mess ups at the begining of the generation, they could hit 360 sales when it all said and done is amazing. Next generation just don't mess up the messaging and keep the console competitively priced and you should do a lot better by default. Also, having Minecraft on xbox and not ps5 should help a lot.
|
Well. To be fair... The Xbox 360 had a ton of issues as well, namely the RROD which tarnished the brand... But despite that, still sold as well as it did.
The Playstation 3 released at a higher price and games often were worst than their Xbox 360 counterparts and sold well.
So, it's not outside of the realm of possibility that a console having a crap launch can still sell well.
Mr Puggsly said:
Fable is still popular, the question is who's gonna continue it? Thus far its just rumors but its silly to think the IP is dead.
Even X1 remasters of the trilogy would be nice just to have the visuals cleaned up for modern consoles. They do well on PC as well given there is a RPG following there.
|
Fable 1 was already remastered with Fable: Anniversary. - I would not complain if they remastered all three again as titles taking full advantage of the Xbox One X. - Although, they would need to do some serious work to Fable 3 to make it a decent title.
Mr Puggsly said:
Anybody who thought X1X would turn things around completely should have just been ignored.
|
Agreed. We had the Playstation 4 as the precedent to go by.
The Xbox One X will help overall sales though, especially as it's a Halo product... Which means it's got the best visuals and that is being reflected in general trailers, advertising and marketing material, which should hopefully be noticed by consumers.