By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Movies & TV - The Fans Have Spoken, Last Jedi Drops A Massive 68%

Lucas-Rio said:

The few scenes that were removed were even more outrageous. This director has no clue.

Im curious... which scenes?



Around the Network
Goodnightmoon said:
Lucas-Rio said:

Every day, the ratings of this movie are dropping on all website, and everyday the legs in the box office in several countries is falling.

Every day, the consensus in the audience is that film sucked. You (movie lovers) are clearly losing.

Is called a hate bandwagoon, something that people without personality jumps in.  This movie was awesome, when time passes and people finally starts to accept the changes and the natural evolution of the saga things will change, it has happened a lot of times in cinema, I already seen this happening a bunch of times just no so exagerated, I hope you still here when that happens, is gonna fun.

I couldn’t agree more.  



Something...Something...Games...Something

Goodnightmoon said:
Lucas-Rio said:

Every day, the ratings of this movie are dropping on all website, and everyday the legs in the box office in several countries is falling.

Every day, the consensus in the audience is that film sucked. You (movie lovers) are clearly losing.

Is called a hate bandwagoon, something that people without personality jumps in.  This movie was awesome, when time passes and people finally starts to accept the changes and the natural evolution of the saga things will change, it has happened a lot of times in cinema, I already seen this happening a bunch of times just no so exagerated, I hope you still here when that happens, is gonna fun.

Er... all products have hate bandwagons. TLJ is not an exception to the rule. Breath of the Wild had its fair share of haters and some of them even had large fanbases like Jim Sterling. However, the game was so good that it went on to sell a ton and won a lot of GOTY awards. This is not the case with TLJ. The several criticisms made against the movie were not the result from nostalgia bias and blind hate. From the plot holes to contrived developments that many people pointed to, TLJ was not a good movie to a lot of people.

To just handwave these flaws away as the "natural evolution" is a poor argument. Change for the sake of change never ends well. It's how you make those changes and so far, I have seen very little elaboration on how these changes are more positive than negative.



Vincoletto said:
thismeintiel said:

I don't know. With all the other messages they had so on the nose, it wouldn't surprise me that's the exact reason why they did it. I think they wanted a girl Jedi, which is perfectly fine, but didn't want her to have to struggle too  much. Either because they felt like girls wouldn't want to watch her suffer through those struggles or they didn't want the male Jedis to look so powerful next to a female, even though we know those males had to go through the same struggles. Whichever it is, it's insulting to the audience's intelligence, as well as women, thinking they wouldn't be interested in or couldn't handle a female protagonist who isn't perfect.

 

I really hate playing this card, but part of me thinks its because they would not accept having a male (Luke) teaching her everything, patronizing her and in the end being responsible for a huge part of her development. It was important to pass the message that she, as a female, could achieve everything without the help of a man. Usually I dont have this kind of thinking but judging based on what happens in the rest of the movie I feel inclined to think this way. I really hope im wrong.

Well, considering the rest of the movie, especially the scenes with Purple Hair, it wouldn't surprise me if that was the case. It pisses me off that people can think so lowly of women that they can't handle a weaker woman being trained, even if it's by a man, to become one of the best. And supposed feminist support that? To me, it seems so demeaning.

Lucas-Rio said: 
Goodnightmoon said: 

Also is suyrprising the level of doble moral that some fans have, like 2/3 of the "defects" they find in the new ones are already there in the original trilogy, but is like cannot fucking see them, and as a consequence there are more and more memes about it




Nobody would have complained if Luke ended like Obiwan or Yoda.

- They weren't depressed and weak nor grumbling

- They actually trained Luke and were useful in the story

- They never tried to kill their nephews in their sleep

- They were not overwhelmed by powerless kid..... Obiwan defeated Anakin and Yoda fought Sidious , the most powerful sith , to a draw.  Luke was knocked out by a weak Kylo Ren and never redeemed himself.

 

Johnson pissed on Luke Skywalker, and that's why his movie is hated. Not only it's a very bad movie, but it's a disgusting movie, a franchise destroyer, something that left a disgusting taste in your mouth. I don't think I will watch episode 9 if they don't immediately correct the course. I will wait the true fans reactions before, for sure. It killed any anticipation.

Exactly. Besides, it's not like the prequels did the best at setting up how the characters got to where they are at the beginning of the OG trilogy. Really I always took it that Yoda was either exiled or he got shot down over Degobah. And Obi-Wan had to give up on a war he knew he could not win in order to watch over Luke, in case Vader ever came looking for him.

Luke, on the other hand, just left as soon as his apprentice fought back in what was basically self defense. Instead of reaching out to him before he could actually join the Order, he ran away and left everyone with his fuck up. He then is turned off by the whole Jedi belief system because? Oh, just because the script said so. Really? You couldn't write something he found out that turned him away from it? It's just because HE, not the Jedi,  fucked up once?

It's not only a worse setup, it doesn't fit with his character, as he has always been the most optimistic one of the three. He left Yoda when both Yoda and Obi-Wan said he needed to stay and train, even if his friends had to die as a result. They thought Vader was beyond redemption, but he believed he wasn't no matter how many times they put doubt there. 



eva01beserk said:
Puppyroach said:

Yes, my mistake regarding who made those points. But I was questioning what the purpose was of those points. In what way does the movie portray that Rey got her gifts because she was a woman (point 1) and in what way did the movie portray Kylo as weaker compared to Rey because he was a man (point 6)?

It was never going to. If you had not notice, that would be a huge negative and if it was obvious the backlash would be immense.  The same as ghost busters, they dint say man are stupid or evil, and women are always right, man hold women back, women aren't trusted. But they implied all of that by the actions and events that occured, like making the 2 main male characters a handsome idiot, and an evil nerd, then combine them for the ultimate evil. All the man in power thought they where crazy, useless and made everything possible to stand in their way. The women had always a strong belief in their goals, even though everyone was against them, they have a momentary lapse of faith to them be proven right almost immediately and everybody sees the folly of their way. So women perfect, man flawed. 

I wont go into how star wars did the same cuz it was pointed out multiple times in this thread. 

You say you have no problems arguing the points made, why don't you? Its more productive that asumin sexim. 

Yeah, you sound way to much like a feminist, only they complain bout how males are portrayed compared to women in movies. Do you feel the same way about the 2nd Alien movie for example where the men are generally morons or bad guys? I think you are reading way to much into things.



Around the Network
Mr.GameCrazy said:

I know The Last Jedi is very divided when it comes to the audience, but I think it's a huge exaggeration to say that it's a franchise destroyer. I honestly wonder if people thought that way at the time the prequel trilogy was released.

The prequel trilogy hate was real.

And the prequels did destroy the franchise, and one of the reasons The Force Awakens had so much hype was because we wanted to pretend the prequels never happened.

The Last Jedi is almost as bad as the prequels.



Puppyroach said:
eva01beserk said:

It was never going to. If you had not notice, that would be a huge negative and if it was obvious the backlash would be immense.  The same as ghost busters, they dint say man are stupid or evil, and women are always right, man hold women back, women aren't trusted. But they implied all of that by the actions and events that occured, like making the 2 main male characters a handsome idiot, and an evil nerd, then combine them for the ultimate evil. All the man in power thought they where crazy, useless and made everything possible to stand in their way. The women had always a strong belief in their goals, even though everyone was against them, they have a momentary lapse of faith to them be proven right almost immediately and everybody sees the folly of their way. So women perfect, man flawed. 

I wont go into how star wars did the same cuz it was pointed out multiple times in this thread. 

You say you have no problems arguing the points made, why don't you? Its more productive that asumin sexim. 

Yeah, you sound way to much like a feminist, only they complain bout how males are portrayed compared to women in movies. Do you feel the same way about the 2nd Alien movie for example where the men are generally morons or bad guys? I think you are reading way to much into things.

Does that make me a meninist? Im ok with that. 

I cant say I remember what the 2nd movie is. I remember the first one somewhat, then resurrection a little bit less(im not sure what number that is). But what I remember ripley was no mary sue. She could not fight them, neither could the men. In resurrection she said it was a mistake to try and manipulate them but she was very much afraid. In all the movies her attitude was we are no match we should run. and the movies where great without having to make her an ass kicking character. Her and the mech suit was well played, pretty sure any man could have used it and fought the queen.



It takes genuine talent to see greatness in yourself despite your absence of genuine talent.

NightlyPoe said:
Lucas-Rio said:

 

Seriously, you should stop writting non sense like this. There is no "work" bewteen Luke/Rey. Nothing. We get one hour of a depressed and weak old man grumbling.

It's the most lazy work ever. We have that in every TV show/movie. Old , depressed people who are self defeating and refuse to do anything. If it wasn't Star Wars, Luke would have had some wiskhy bottles right next to him.

It was lazy and disgusting. The fans outright rejected it. They are more clever than you think.

At its basic, sure.  But expanding from there, playing with the legendary status, tearing it down, reaffirming it.  Playing with the flaws that Luke possessed in the Original Trilogy.  Giving Kylo Ren an actual solid motivation for turning to the Dark Side beyond Vader fanboyism.  Building a connection between Rey and Ben.  It's a solid storyline.

I have no problem criticizing Star Wars movies at this point in my life.  The other half of the movie was a distraction at best.  But Rey/Ben/Luke was a very well-told and powerful story.  The gut reaction from some fanboys actually enforces it.  Feeling betrayed by Luke's moment of weakness was exactly the idea.  You're highlighting a feature, not a bug.

I totally agree with this. I felt the chase part with the rebels was more of a filler ut the Luke/Rey/Kylo piece was some of the best in Star Wars. Luke showed how much it affected him that he couldn´t be stronger when it came to Hans and Leias son and decided to live alone while still leaving clues to his whereabouts. The acting in the scenes on the island were great and made me love Luke as a character more than ever actually.



Puppyroach said:

Yeah, you sound way to much like a feminist, only they complain bout how males are portrayed compared to women in movies. Do you feel the same way about the 2nd Alien movie for example where the men are generally morons or bad guys? I think you are reading way to much into things.

And if I were to watch a movie where women were either evil, stupid, or cowards while the male lead was a perfect Adonis, I would make the same complaints. But that isn't acceptable anymore, despite it being perfectly acceptable to flip the fenders and do the same thing.



Watch me stream games and hunt trophies on my Twitch channel!

Check out my Twitch Channel!:

www.twitch.tv/AzurenGames

mZuzek said:
Goodnightmoon said:

I have already seen it twice and I see the same, a great movie for the franchise, and so do most people around me and almost every single professional critic.

I think that just goes to show just how brutally out of touch with their audiences the professional critics and the movie industry are.

Indeed. Thankfully, the force awakens, and the public has seen how terrible is this film. No "professional" critic is saving this.



Proud to be the first cool Nintendo fan ever

Number ONE Zelda fan in the Universe

DKCTF didn't move consoles

Prediction: No Zelda HD for Wii U, quietly moved to the succesor

Predictions for Nintendo NX and Mobile