By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Now Loading: Would You Rather Buy a Xbox One X or PS4 Pro?

I'd put together a decent gaming PC... but I won't do that either.

As for consoles, I already have a baker's dozen hooked up to my home theater. I'm not really too keen to add anything expensive to the setup. I have a Switch and PS4 and I'm all set for current gen ATM.



Retro Tech Select - My Youtube channel. Covers throwback consumer electronics with a focus on "vid'ya games."

Latest Video: Top 12: Best Games on the N64 - Special Features, Episode 7

Around the Network

Right now, my wallet’s plate is full until x-mas, but early next year, I’ll be sure to get it. I prefer the first party outings from Sony and Nintendo, but considering MS’s push for enhanced retro compatibility, the fact that the X doubles as a UHD player, and considering I’m coming late in the gen to finally game on X-Box, which means there are now enough good exclusives that interest me, and with my TV starving for 4K content, and... It costs much less than what my next PC will cost me (which I keep pushing the purchase back xD)...

I’ll be getting the X in the coming months.

 

Probably right in time for Ori and the Will of the Wisps.



If i didnt have them already and had to make a choice, i would get a second hand PS4 and a Switch over an Xbox One X.
But since I do already have them (PS4 Pro + Switch), I'd rather buy games for the PS4 and Switch over an Xbox One X.

The sad reality is that the Xbox One X is going to be the first console/console upgrade since the Snes that I did not buy on day one, there just isn't a pull for me at all with the whole "it's 4k guys" thing, and the fact that all of the consoles games I can buy for PC, for less just makes it seem like an entirely pointless purchase, so I've not preordered one, and won't be picking one up any time soon, or in the foreseeable future.

If my launch console ever dies (which is unlikely since it's only ever really used to play videos off of the NAS server), i *might* just replace it with an Xbox One X depending on the pricing at that entirely arbitrary point, but only if an Xbox One S isn't available new at that time too.

The depressing thing about this is that I can probably see myself treating the next Xbox console release in the same way, and skipping it entirely and sticking with PlayStation and Nintendo.

Microsoft have slowly diluted the Xbox brand to a point where it's tasteless and unappetizing, where as it's competition just keep on perfecting their formula and making their offerings tastier with each passing year.

Last edited by NATO - on 08 November 2017

I got a PC for games so ps4 pro all way., and even with a PC i only got 2 indies games from microsoft exlusivity so ^^



WHY would anybody choose the Xbox one x over a PS4 pro or even a standard PS4?
Sony console is lightyears the better console to own. It’s games we want and it’s games that Sony’s console has much more of than Microsoft’s and it’s also still pumping them out while Microsoft just sits there doing nothing.



PSN ID: Stokesy 

Add me if you want but let me know youre from this website

Around the Network

Feel good thread of the year!



So nice of you to ask. Yes, I would buy a PC rather than a PS4 Pro. Dunno why I would call it Xbox One X though.



If you demand respect or gratitude for your volunteer work, you're doing volunteering wrong.

Zekkyou said:
LudicrousSpeed said:

lol this was quoted by a mod.

Indeed, moderators are able to post things in mod chat and ask a user to expand on their comment in the meantime. Our power is great, our wisdom boundless, and our knowledge of changes in user image quality preferences kept sealed in the under-forum vaults.

I'm sure you're still referring to me with that last part, but rest assured, no changes in preference regarding resolution here, friend. Scorpio is about a lot more than true 4k, don't fall for the PR :) Either way, I'm glad you at least have an idea about what you think my opinion is, even if it's misguided. That's better than the adorable fishing you used to do in every single Scorpio thread lol.



Neither. If I'd ever get a Playstation or XBox, I'd take the cheapest version. There doesn't seem to be a lot of difference between the cheap and the expensive models.



LudicrousSpeed said:
Zekkyou said:

If the X1X is worth it to someone whose previously expressed apathy to image quality/graphics (such as yourself), someone that already cared about those things is likley to value a Pro to a comparable degree. Especially since they're paying quite a bit less. I know I've been quite happy with the Pro. Not amazed, but it's been worth the entry price.

The dynamic obviously further shifts if you're dealing with someone that doesn't own a PS4 at all.

Apathy to image quality/graphics is not accurate at all. Apathy to the blown out of proportions difference between Xbone and PS4 that we saw a million threads about at launch and for awhile after, sure. And the PS4 to Pro represents that same small leap in quality. Fortunately the Scorpio is a massive upgrade to the Xbone, and also has lots of features built in that spruce games up even better. Some of the BC games for example look amazing, as already mentioned in the thread. Plus super sampling support built right in, yowza. That one is less of a draw for me personally because I am waiting to replace the 4k TV my son broke before buying a Scorpio.

The dynamic obviously further shifts if you’re dealing with someone that already owns a PS4 and Xbone and prefers the userface, network, and controller of Xbone.

So the difference between X1X to PS4Pro is higher than from PS4 to X1??? Seems just like that MS PR person saying X1X wouldn't compete with Pro, because it was so above that PS4Pro would be competing with X1S.

Pemalite said:
If you like the Playstation exclusives. Get the Playstation 4 Pro.

If you like the er... Xbox exclusives? Get the Xbox One X.

If you don't give a crap about brands like myself... Then get both or neither.

Also... Those claiming that the Playstation 4 Pro/Xbox One X is a waste because they are still using a 1080P display... Well. Sorry to break it to you, but there are some large visual enhancements even at 1080P, you truly are missing out on extra fidelity.

And you could potentially be buying a 4K TV in the next 4 years... so if you don't have any 8th gen console a X1X or PS4Pro would be a better choice (if money allows), but for most the upgrade isn't worthwhile unfortunatelly (even if they have 4k set).

DroidKnight said:
LivingMetal said:

The far majority of responses in this thread has been in favor off the PS4 Pro. So is that supposed to mean  vgchartz is a Playstation website?

Absolutely  not,  this website has an equal representation of Xbox, Pc, Ps, and Nin.  It is in no way skewed towards Ps or Nin or anything else.

Errr no... Nintendo > PS >>>>>> PC > X1 in representation here.

hinch said:

If I HAD to pick one, it would be PS4 Pro, for the games. Though neither consoles are really enticing enough for me to purchase one or another.

I have a pretty okay specced PC, so Xbox One X doesn't do anything for me. And PS4 Pro doesn't really offer enough of an upgrade over the original PS4..

Plus, I want both consoles to fail/not meet their expectations so that Sony/MS might have rethink their strategy for launch cycles. I want shorter generations, not stop gaps that prolongs advancements in games tech.

Well, Sony have said in all PR that PS4 is beating their expectations and X1X have had 2 batches of pre-order filled and there is backorder, so it be a success.



duduspace11 "Well, since we are estimating costs, Pokemon Red/Blue did cost Nintendo about $50m to make back in 1996"

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8808363

Mr Puggsly: "Hehe, I said good profit. You said big profit. Frankly, not losing money is what I meant by good. Don't get hung up on semantics"

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=9008994

Azzanation: "PS5 wouldn't sold out at launch without scalpers."