By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Super Mario Odyssey Reviews - 97 Metacritic (91 Reviews) - 97 OpenCritic (84 Reviews)

It just dropped a point in OpenCritic. 98 now.

It went a point up in Metacritic, 97 now.



Around the Network

So, another critical acclaim? Well, that's nice. Well done, Nintendo . Now, it's time to give it the ultimate score. MINE! XD.



Volterra_90 said:

Guys, I'm hyped as everyone for this game, but let's keep it civil if certain publications give a score you don't agree with. It happens, and I'm tired of people diminishing the value of the review by saying that it's just click-baiting. I read some 10/10 reviews which are badly written and don't hold any value, yet I read some 7/10 reviews (heh, see what I did here? ) which are, at least, better written and explain its reasons clearly. Everyone has his/her own opinion, and we should celebrate that. In the end, what really matters is your own opinion, stick to that, and enjoy the ride

EDIT: It's a good time to play Jump up, Super Star! on repeat. It increases the hype XD.

Hear, hear. We're just encouraging critics to inflate scores by losing our shit every time a game gets less than an 8/10.



LimaBean01 said:
One person on metacritic gave it 75 -_- take a good look at yourself and ask if it really deserves that...

"PLAY! Zine
Oct 26, 2017
75
Though a really neat game, Super Mario Odyssey is an utterly underwhelming adventure for every long-term Super Mario fan in existence. Unless Cappy brainwashed you. In that case, you are a satisfied zombie customer now. No, seriously, only a zombie would find a healthy challenge in this pleasant but disappointingly easy Super Mario Walk-in-the-park. Sorry - Odyssey."

I'll see after playing the game, but the way he's written this comes off either very immaturely, or like he's trying to provoke people.

Never heard of the outlet either.



Veknoid_Outcast said:
Volterra_90 said:

Guys, I'm hyped as everyone for this game, but let's keep it civil if certain publications give a score you don't agree with. It happens, and I'm tired of people diminishing the value of the review by saying that it's just click-baiting. I read some 10/10 reviews which are badly written and don't hold any value, yet I read some 7/10 reviews (heh, see what I did here? ) which are, at least, better written and explain its reasons clearly. Everyone has his/her own opinion, and we should celebrate that. In the end, what really matters is your own opinion, stick to that, and enjoy the ride

EDIT: It's a good time to play Jump up, Super Star! on repeat. It increases the hype XD.

Hear, hear. We're just encouraging critics to inflate scores by losing our shit every time a game gets less than an 8/10.

Yep, I'm fearing what would happen now with that 75/100 score from Odyssey. Though, tbh, the review is actually pretty bad in this case imho XD. I mean, you read it and it seems like it's almost trollish. That wasn't the case with the 70/100 review from Jim Sterling in BOTW, which actually make some points which I think were fair. 



Around the Network

It feels like the entire internet is slower. Nice scores. The one 75 review from Playzine looked absolutely dumb and childishly written. There's always that one guy...



Shaunodon said:
LimaBean01 said:
One person on metacritic gave it 75 -_- take a good look at yourself and ask if it really deserves that...

"PLAY! Zine
Oct 26, 2017
75
Though a really neat game, Super Mario Odyssey is an utterly underwhelming adventure for every long-term Super Mario fan in existence. Unless Cappy brainwashed you. In that case, you are a satisfied zombie customer now. No, seriously, only a zombie would find a healthy challenge in this pleasant but disappointingly easy Super Mario Walk-in-the-park. Sorry - Odyssey."

I'll see after playing the game, but the way he's written this comes off either very immaturely, or like he's trying to provoke people.

Never heard of the outlet either.

Yep. The way he calls anyone who would rate it highly a zombie comes off as reactionary and trying to get attention :/



Damn, Metacritic is struggling right now.



Signature goes here!

Metacritic can't handle that much traffic.



Scores:

TrueGaming 10.0 / 10.0
GameSpot 10 / 10
Press Start 10 / 10
NintendoWorldReport 10.0 / 10.0
Metro GameCentral 10 / 10
GamesRadar+ 100 / 100
Nintendo Enthusiast 10.0 / 10.0
Digitally Downloaded 100 / 100
FNintendo 10 / 10
Guardian 100 / 100
GamesBeat 100 / 100
Critical Hit 10.0 / 10.0
COGconnected 100 / 100
USgamer 100 / 100
Cubed3 10 / 10
Giant Bomb 100 / 100
Game Revolution 100 / 100
Nintendo Life 10 / 10
TheSixthAxis 10 / 10
IBTimes UK 100 / 100
Areajugones 10.0 / 10.0
Gameblog 10 / 10
IGN 10.0 / 10.0
Hobby Consolas 98 / 100
AusGamers 9.8 / 10.0
Game Informer 9.8 / 10.0
Wccftech 9.7 / 10.0
Spaziogames 9.5 / 10.0
CGMagazine 9.5 / 10.0
ThisGenGaming 9.5 / 10.0
Polygon 95 / 100
NZGamer 9.5 / 10.0
GBAtemp 8.0 / 10.0
Expansive 10 / 10
SA Gamer 10 / 10
Red Value Gaming 95 / 100
PowerUp! 9.5 / 10.0