I'm with most others and don't consider The Last of Us a PS4 exclusive. I'd rate Horizon above U4. I'd probably rate Bloodborne above both, but it would be close.

Yakuza 0
Persona 5
Nier Automata

I really enjoyed them all, but Horizon Zero Dawn brought something new with the gameplay. Bringing down a Metal Hawk was soooooo Fn AWESOME.

Im going with Horizon Zero Dawn.

The Best Exclusive isn't even out yet...

The Last of Us Part II

Just like the poll....

1. TLOU
2. Horizon
3. U4

Uncharted 4 is a great game but the other two are just deeper and more appealing to me.

That said, if I’d chose the whole Uncharted franchise I’d surely put it above Horizon.

All are amazing games. Luxury problems.

Regardless of my ranking I‘d give the OP the advice to start with the Uncharted collection, then U4, then Horizon for some variation, then Uncharted Lost Legacy and then TLOU. I wouldn’t necessarily start with the best game first.

God I hope you don’t have a job or family ;D

I'd say he should play the Collection then play TLoU and Horizon before going back to Uncharted 4 so when he gets back to UC4 is not burnt out of the genre.

None of those, The last guardian is obviously.

Persona 5

Edit - Ugh I keep forgetting that Persona has a PS3 version.In this case then, its Bloodborne that I choose!

YES!! I think so too. Best STORY, Best Characters !! Gameplay / Soundtracks / Design are amazing too.

for me: Persona 5 and Yakuza Zero. And The Last of Us + Uncharted 4. But Ni No Kuni 2, Detroit Become Human, God of War and many other awesome Games are coming. Its very exciting. And best graphic now: Uncharted 4. But Horizon Zero Dawn has the biggest worlds.

Unfortunely Persona 5 is not a candidate for this list, given that it is not a PS4 exclusive.

But a masterpiece of a game, no doubt.