Not toxic at all - 99,99% of the things I say on the Internet I also would say in real life if people were standing next to me. I wished that all people would do it the same way, but I unfortunately know it never will work out like that.
To me trolling and writing obviously wrong things makes no sense at all.
I guess i would be veeeery strict if I was some kind of forum moderator.
Edit:
I would be a kind of moderator who instantly temp-bans people for going into a thread and posting how less they care about the topic or people which simply say something like "xxx is crap" without any reasonable explanation.