1. A new Punch-Out!!, with new characters (I loved the Wii version, but I'd like to see what new boxers they could come up with).
2. New Ace Attorney from Capcom (once the 3DS winds down)
3. New Prof. Layton from Level-5 (see #2)
4. New Metroid game that rewards exploration rather than speedrunning.
5. New WarioWare game with 200+ microgames, not a dozen or so minigames.
6. Just some classic Nintendo franchises, such as Donkey Kong Country, Kid Icarus, etc.
That's what I'd love to see anyway.