By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Wait, DID Horizon First Week Global Sales Really Outpace BotW's? (PLEASE READ FIRST POST)

 

Which did you enjoy more?

Breath of the Wild 402 32.74%
 
Horizon: Zero Dawn 377 30.70%
 
I haven't played both yet/Unsure 286 23.29%
 
See Results 163 13.27%
 
Total:1,228
F.Scofield said:
TheBlackNaruto said:

 

Again where was there a mock in the OP or thread title? So being surprised that a brand new IP from a developer that has only reallly done FPS shooter games beating a huge franchise like Zelda is mocking really? How? And because you assumed it was mocking your thought was wellni am going to mock back? Okay....to each his/her own I guess.

  Maybe it's not mocking but definitely is playing with data here, i don't know if people has short memory or what but it's pretty easy, just go to the vgcharts page and check EVERY single zelda game and it's first month numbers, Zelda was never a front loaded franchise as people are painting it to be here, it always had decent but humble numbers compared to other nintendo franchises, just look at the npd numbers, it sold 900k on switch during an entire month, it's a record within zelda sales but if you compare to other franchises from nintendo it's not even an impressive number 

   What makes zelda selling good is it's legs, so yeah, taking a game that was never front loaded and on a console supply constrained isn't a good comparison, maybe in a year we'll have the larger picture but using zelda to praise horizon sales is just...a better comparison to horizon would be ghost recon but when we compare a REAL front loaded franchise both horizon and zelda sales looks mediocre compared to it.

Wait.....it is not even playing with data. Who ever said Zelda was front loaded lol? Literally NO ONE has said that or even made that out to be the case, The only thing this thread and the OP said was that it was surprising(and it is) that a brand new franchise that is unproven. Did better first week than a game that is as big as Zelda. How is that in anyway or form playing with data or acting as if Zelda was front loaded? Heck again MOST people didn't even think that Horizon would sell lifetime what it sold in under 2 weeks. So add that to the fact that it outdid Zelda FW then it was surprising and impressive. And that is all the OP said.

Also yes the Switch was supply constrained but there were about 13 million Wii U users so we can't  just ignore them. 



The absence of evidence is NOT the evidence of absence...

PSN: StlUzumaki23

Around the Network
TheBlackNaruto said:

Wait.....it is not even playing with data. Who ever said Zelda was front loaded lol? Literally NO ONE has said that or even made that out to be the case, The only thing this thread and the OP said was that it was surprising(and it is) that a brand new franchise that is unproven. Did better first week than a game that is as big as Zelda. How is that in anyway or form playing with data or acting as if Zelda was front loaded? Heck again MOST people didn't even think that Horizon would sell lifetime what it sold in under 2 weeks. So add that to the fact that it outdid Zelda FW then it was surprising and impressive. And that is all the OP said.

Also yes the Switch was supply constrained but there were about 13 million Wii U users so we can't  just ignore them. 

Really? No one?

StreaK said:

That's foolish of you to say. Word of mouth is so strong with HZD. It will keep selling. I imagine it will outleg Zelda because most people that want the game are already lined up for it. Just look at a movie like Avatar. No one knew what the heck it was but word of mouth kept its weekly $$$$ from falling. I think Zelda will quickly die out as I think it is very frontloaded while HZD has far more room to grow as it's such a new IP.

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8386951



StarDoor said:
TheBlackNaruto said:

Wait.....it is not even playing with data. Who ever said Zelda was front loaded lol? Literally NO ONE has said that or even made that out to be the case, The only thing this thread and the OP said was that it was surprising(and it is) that a brand new franchise that is unproven. Did better first week than a game that is as big as Zelda. How is that in anyway or form playing with data or acting as if Zelda was front loaded? Heck again MOST people didn't even think that Horizon would sell lifetime what it sold in under 2 weeks. So add that to the fact that it outdid Zelda FW then it was surprising and impressive. And that is all the OP said.

Also yes the Switch was supply constrained but there were about 13 million Wii U users so we can't  just ignore them. 

Really? No one?

StreaK said:

That's foolish of you to say. Word of mouth is so strong with HZD. It will keep selling. I imagine it will outleg Zelda because most people that want the game are already lined up for it. Just look at a movie like Avatar. No one knew what the heck it was but word of mouth kept its weekly $$$$ from falling. I think Zelda will quickly die out as I think it is very frontloaded while HZD has far more room to grow as it's such a new IP.

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8386951

You got me there. I didn't  even see that post before I wrote mine lol. Well before that one person I don't recall anyone in the thread saying that.



The absence of evidence is NOT the evidence of absence...

PSN: StlUzumaki23