From what we've seen so far, Zelda. Red Dead looms I'm the distance. Waiting to gun it down.

Of the ones you listed I would hope Persona 5 gets it, but it's probably going to end up being either Zelda or RDR2. I never personally understood the acclaim given to the first Red Dead Redemption, since it was "just" a good game instead of the masterpiece so many made it out to be. Still, Rockstar generally gets very good reception for most of their games, so I wouldn't be surprised to see that happen again.

I'd say it's going to end up being Zelda, most definitely. With the only real competition for the rest of the year being RDR2 and *maybe* Mario Odyssey. I think that most major publications get cold feet when it comes to crowning JRPGs as GOTY, so it rules out Persona 5. And Horizon will probably end up with the lowest Metascore of them all.

Also, the OP should be updated to include PS3 as a platform of release for Persona 5.

Zelda winning a lot of goty is like overwatch winning goty in my opinion.

If Overwatch can win GOTY, and not win in the Best action category.. anything can happen.

Xenoblade 2 will crush everything and will get a 100 Metascore.

From what have been released, obviously Zelda!

I wish.

I feel it's gonna come down to Zelda, Horizon, and RDR2, with maybe RDR2 winning it in the end.

Zelda is hard to beat, I'm not sure if anything is gonna top it. Excellent game, a bit disappointed myself story wise with only a few dungeons but there's so much to do in the game its pretty awesome.