By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft Discussion - The power gap between Scorpio and PS4 Pro might be greater than the Switch and the PS4 Slim.

malistix1985 said:

Sony pretty much pushed the jaquar as far as it can go in the pro and games are not running on 1080/60, take Nier or Dark Souls or Final Fantasy who all aim at that and all fail at that because of CPU limitations (analyzed by digital foundry/VGTech and they said this is the reason)

Jaguar can still be taken farther. For example... We do know that the L2 cache on the CPU is 4x larger than the 8-core Jaguar found in the Xbox One. That's a big difference right there.

But I agree. It would be nice if a console manufacturer took CPU performance seriously for once... But an 8-core Ryzen just seems unlikely.

malistix1985 said:

Anyway, the 480RX which is less powerfull then the scorpio and has less memory bandwith can run rise of the tomb raider, grand theft auto and even newer titles in 4k no problem and when you aim for 30fps games like the witcher and watch dogs are possible if the scorpio has an updated CPU.

The RX480 is a terrible GPU though.

If Microsofts opts for an NCU GPU over a GCN4 GPU... Then Scorpio could have a larger performance advantage than what the pure-flop number implies.

We need hardware specifics to truly know how much of an edge Scorpio will have.

leo-j said:
Also a 299 4k PS4 is more appealing than a 400 4k Xbox

Good thing the Xbox One S will still be around for $199.

malistix1985 said:

I don't know what to expect but I do know Microsoft doesn't want to make the same mistake sony did and have bottlenecks, obv sony's design does a good job of 4k checkerboarding and thats what its designed for but as dice and many other developers have stated, native is ALWAYS easier and doesn't require any work where in checkerboarding does require quite a bit of work.

Scorpio has hinted that it will also support Checkerboarding.
Which means Checkerboarding is not a Sony technique or a Sony invention, but likely an AMD one.

thismeintiel said:

Definitely. If Xbox fans think a 40% more powerful XBO (in comparison to the Pro), with no exclusives, is all MS needs to change things in EU and Japan, they have a rude awakening coming.  PS is a WW brand, where Xbox is only relevant in a handful of countries.

Well. Microsoft would understand that power does not mean a victory... They did have the most powerful 6th generation console remember.

thismeintiel said:

Do you think the different memory setup is going to cause problems for the Scorpio running XBO games? Is that going to be something that needs to be patched?

Microsoft will likely abstract everything that it needs to get around the eSRAM. So I doubt games will need to be individually patched to work on Scorpio.

But they will need to be patched to take advantage of the extra hardware, no way around it.

Games with variable resolutions and games that don't meet their framerate targets should see some gains without any patching though.

Sitti said:

When you are not doing so well, release new more powerful console. That is exactly how Sega lost the game, while Nitendo and Sony focused on supporting their existing systems and, most importantly, games. Even with higher spec, if MS can't match it's price with PS4 Pro, which most certainly they can't, Sony has nothing to worry about MS taking sales away. In fact, MS officially mentioned that Scorpio isn't meant to compete with PS4.

Microsoft's pockets run deeper than Sony's. You can bet your ass that Microsoft can discount Scorpio below the Playstation 4 Pro if they see a need, so don't kid yourself.

I think Microsoft will instead leverage the Xbox One S as the cheaper console alternative though, rather than cut into any profit margins.

Fei-Hung said:


This E 3 should paint a good picture for the future of Xbox. If the games still aren't there outside of Halo, Forza and Gears, I will be seriously concerned. Phil really needs to bring back:

1) otogi
2) jade empire
3) perfect dark
4) a proper Banjo Game

I wouldn't complain if we got a Black and White 3, Fable 4, Freelancer 2, Mechwarrior 5, Age of Empires 4 on top of that.
But I think we are kidding ourselves. Hah.



--::{PC Gaming Master Race}::--

Around the Network

I am excited that MS is bringing out such a powerful console and that they seem to be taking a very games-focused approach.

As much as I think Sony made some real misteps with the PS4Pro, and thats showing in the sales, I also just don't think there is enough appetite for high end consoles for this to be truly *wait for it*....game changing.



starcraft - Playing Games = FUN, Talking about Games = SERIOUS

Don't have to respond they just keep doing what keeps them in the game



zorg1000 said:
EricHiggin said:

There's many possibilities in my opinion. Shooting from downtown on this one.

-PS4 SS ($199) and Pro S ($349) launch. E3 2017.
-PS4 SS ($199), Pro S Digital ($299), Pro 4k BD ($399). E3 2017.
-PS4 Portable teasers. Before E3 2018.
-PS4 Portable launch. E3 2018 ($249).
-PS5 teaser. Before E3 2019.
-PS5 launch. E3 2019. (8 core Zen+, 10Tflop Vega/Navi, 16gb HBM2 ?) ($399).
-PS Phone/Laptop teaser. Before E3 2020.
-PS Phone/Laptop launch. E3 2020.
OR
-PS4 SS ($199) and Pro S ($349) launch, E3 2017.
-PS4 SS ($199), Pro S Digital ($299), Pro 4k BD ($399). E3 2017.
-PS4 Ultra teasers. Before E3 2018.
-PS4 Ultra launch. E3 2018. (8or12 core Jag, 54cu 6.2Tflop Pitcairn/Polaris, 12gb DDR5(x) ?) ($399).
-PS4 Portable teasers. Before E3 2019. 
-PS4 Portable launch. E3 2019.  ($249)
-PS5 teaser. Before E3 2020.
-PS5 launch. E3 2020. (8 core Zen+, 12Tflop Navi, 16gb HBM3 ?) ($399).
-PS Phone/Laptop teaser. Before E3 2021.
-PS Phone/Laptop launch. E3 2021.

i mean literally none of those things are necessary, Sony can just keep doing what they are doing and will outsell XBO/Scorpio.

Yeah, maybe Microsoft can start to gain some ground in US/UK but globally PS4 is going to dominate XBO no matter what.

When you say "literally none of those things are necessary", do you mean to say that PS has no need to ever create another PS4, or a PS5? I can't be sure, even though you said literally, because thats what it sounds like.



Why do people think the Scorpio will be 500$? The HW is around 50% better than the Pro, but also a year newer. Tech advances, and it's not unreasonable to think that the Scorpio could be 400$. As for power not matter, well it mattered to many before, so why should this be different?



Made a bet with LipeJJ and HylianYoshi that the XB1 will reach 30 million before Wii U reaches 15 million. Loser has to get avatar picked by winner for 6 months (or if I lose, either 6 months avatar control for both Lipe and Hylian, or my patrick avatar comes back forever).

Around the Network
barneystinson69 said:

Why do people think the Scorpio will be 500$? The HW is around 50% better than the Pro, but also a year newer. Tech advances, and it's not unreasonable to think that the Scorpio could be 400$. As for power not matter, well it mattered to many before, so why should this be different?

Because a year old tech is still more expensive than 4-5 year old tech. Additionally, they MS are changing and upping far more components than Sony. While Sony just mirrored their bits, MS is adding a UHD, changing RAM type, adding more RAM, possibly changing their GPU etc. Also, I doubt MS will want to sell at a loss at launch. At the very least they will try to break even. 



thismeintiel said:
leo-j said:
Also a 299 4k PS4 is more appealing than a 400 4k Xbox

Definitely. If Xbox fans think a 40% more powerful XBO (in comparison to the Pro), with no exclusives, is all MS needs to change things in EU and Japan, they have a rude awakening coming.  PS is a WW brand, where Xbox is only relevant in a handful of countries.

Why even ponder something so laughably ludicrous and non-existent? Has anyone said anything remotely close to "more power = they outsell PS worldwide" besides some random YouTube or twitter personality just trying to rile people up for clicks? It's bizarre, since the day this thing was made official, people with no interest in owning one are building it up as something much more than even those of us who are buying it are expecting it to be. I mean hell, Xbox fans know more than anyone that the best hardware doesn't guarantee you jack squat aside from the best looking and performing games (exception being 3rd party PS3). Let me speak for all the rational people who are going to buy the Scorpio and put this to rest. No, we aren't expecting a 10TF God in a box PC compatible monster, and we aren't expecting Xbox to suddenly become the #1 brand in gaming. We're expecting the same thing we saw with PS Pro, a niche product at a premium price that enthusiasts will buy but pretty much no one else.

Hopefully, though, the games just have less trouble performing with upgrades than they have thus far on the Pro :)



Who cares. Just going to have nothing but Halo Gears Forza remasters....Again...

 

Hows Horizon Zero Dawn and Persona 5 and Breath of the Wild and Tales of Berseria and Kingdom Hearts and The Last of Us and Ni no  Kuni  run on Scorpio?  I can't wait to see it! /Snicker

 

I guess there's always Halo Ultimate Ultra Super No We Really Mean It This Time Guys HDHDHD8K Edition.... With a $300 collector edition  without the game which contains a steel book to hold your used download code.



malistix1985 said:
exclusive_console said:

Yes I guess older games can run at 4K. May be like Tomb Raider they will have different modes ?? I am not sure about current or future games though.Xbone and PS4 will be base and PS4P, Scorpio will have higher res support.

Didn't horizon run from a checkerboarded 1800P, if this is the case and scorpio is at least 40% more powerfull and has 4GB of faster ram available and god knows what kind of cpu, it should be able to run that game in full 4k, obviously it wont since its exclusive but isn't that one of the better looking games?

Anyway, the 480RX which is less powerfull then the scorpio and has less memory bandwith can run rise of the tomb raider, grand theft auto and even newer titles in 4k no problem and when you aim for 30fps games like the witcher and watch dogs are possible if the scorpio has an updated CPU.

Tomb raider runs at 4K on PS4P so yeah it is possible but it really depends on dev and gfx fidelity needs to be scarificed.



 

exclusive_console said:
malistix1985 said:

Didn't horizon run from a checkerboarded 1800P, if this is the case and scorpio is at least 40% more powerfull and has 4GB of faster ram available and god knows what kind of cpu, it should be able to run that game in full 4k, obviously it wont since its exclusive but isn't that one of the better looking games?

Anyway, the 480RX which is less powerfull then the scorpio and has less memory bandwith can run rise of the tomb raider, grand theft auto and even newer titles in 4k no problem and when you aim for 30fps games like the witcher and watch dogs are possible if the scorpio has an updated CPU.

Tomb raider runs at 4K on PS4P so yeah it is possible but it really depends on dev and gfx fidelity needs to be scarificed.

Tomb raider doesn't run in native 4k on the PS4P at all




Twitter @CyberMalistix