Yea well, if its not achieving 60fps on the ps4 pro, it won't achieve 60fps on a 960. It also runs at 1080p on a ps4 pro instead of say, 1440p checkerboard like most other games so... Its pretty easy to see why you would have to turn it down to a medium in order to achieve 60fps since a 960 is closer to a regular ps4 in terms of performance than a ps4 pro. From what I hear, the high settings on it defaults to 8x MSAA which is very demanding. So anyone trying high preset should really turn it down to 4x MSAA or lower.
The port, while not the greatest is certainly not really that bad when you are considering how the consoles are performing. This isn't a PC only issue when the ps4 pro which runs games like Horizon at 1440p+ smoothly only manages to run Nier at 1080p. So considering that, the performance you are getting with a 960 is pretty much on par with what people should expect considering how its performing on consoles imo. There are of course, some bugs which do need to be fixed.