Well since Yakuza 0 is also on the PS3, Digimon is holding down a 67% on Metacritic and I'm playing Nier on my PC... It looks like HZD is the winner for me!

I didn't play Horizon, I don't like ranged combat or the setting.
Im in love with NioH, its a good exclusive.

Anyway, Im playing Nier Automata on the PC right now and its one of the very best games I have played in many years, with forza horizon 3 and the witcher 3 this is in my top 3 of games of the generation for me.

So I voted Nier. This might change to Persona 5 tough, since Persona 3 and 4 are some of my all time fav games

My favorite played new PlayStation console exclusive of the year is Horizon Zero Dawn. After that I have a bit a a backlog I need to complete :
1) Horizon Zero Dawn
2) Finish Uncharted 4
3) Finish The Last of Us Remastered (more importantly Left Behind)
4) Gravity Rush Remastered
5) Gravity Rush 2
6) Nier: Automata
7) Nioh
8) Finish Bloodborne.

Strange list. Sad but true.

This^

I  had a blast with Yakuza 0 (my first Yakuza game btw) and now really enjoyin my time with Horizon. 

It is silly that this still has to be explained. Sigh.....anyway on topic

I haven't even open Nier, Horizon, Yakuza  0, Digimon or Nioh yet. I am on Tales of B right now so I can't decide yet smh.....So many freaking games to play and so very little time....with Persona 5 right around the corner my back log will just continue to grow......and it is only freaking March! That is INSANE!!!

Horizon, then Nier/GR2

1. Horizon 2. Nioh 3. Nier Automata 4. Gravity Rush 2 5. Yakuza 0

I expect Persona 5 to lodge itself above a few of these. 

Currently NiOH, followed very close by Horizon.

But I have the impression Persona 5 will take the lead in a few days.

The PS4 has officially hit its stride! We are in for a ride until .. well, if PS5 is a PS4 PRO Expertm there is no reason to have a generational break! so always!