Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Would you Prefer a Remake of Gen IV or Another One of Gen I

Gen I or Gen IV?

Gen I
Gen IV
Another Gen
mZuzek said:
aceburg0413 said:
I would much rather a sequel to the Kanto region, as opposed to a remake once more, ala Black and White 2, to which I actually hated, I hate you Speedo Pig evo line... forcing me to choose the non fire type for the first time ever... sorry, rage building.

Oh please. Fire types almost always suck. After Charizard, the only ones that were *decent* were Typhlosion and Delphox... Infernape, ehh. Maybe.

The other ones are awful. Grass and Water starters are where it's at.

Incineroar is pretty badass.



Around the Network
Jpcc86 said:
mZuzek said:

Oh please. Fire types almost always suck. After Charizard, the only ones that were *decent* were Typhlosion and Delphox... Infernape, ehh. Maybe.

The other ones are awful. Grass and Water starters are where it's at.

If you talk design alone, sure, whatever floats your boat. But gameplay-wise Blaziken is the single-most useful and powerful starter of all, not just fire types alone. Its even banned from most competitive tiers cause its so broken. -_- 

Of course I'm talking design alone, that's what matters when it comes to liking a Pokémon or not. And Blaziken being the best starter ever is debatable, since Greninja exists. Then again, I never found either of them to be as OP as people make them out to be, they're honestly not that hard to deal with. And then there's Mega Charizard and Mega Venusaur, which are both pretty insane as well.



I am convinced that Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 is the greatest movie ever and people just don't want to accept it.

If we're talking full out 3D open world. A true Console Pokemon. Gimme GEN 1 All Day every day. Specifically Pokemon Yellow Fam. INJECT IT RIGHT HERE

FACT: Anyone Who Says That MGS has little to no stealth elements or it "Pales" In Comparisons to Splinter Cell's Stealth Have Never played an MGS Game and Achieved The Big Boss Ranking.

R.I.P- Solid "Old" Snake and Zack Fair- You Guys are Heroes

Black Women Are The Most Beautiful Women On The Planet.

"In video game terms, RPGs are games that involve a form of separate battles taking place with a specialized battle system and the use of a system that increases your power through a form of points.

Sure, what you say is the definition, but the connotation of RPGs is what they are in video games." - dtewi


We already have a remake of Pokemon Blue and Red. We don't need a re-re-make. I mean, really people. What the hell lol. I'll take a brand new game over one I've beaten 100 times before any day of the week.



Acevil said:

With full potential of the switch I would say remake of the first one, insanely more money to be made. 

The newest games have already sold 15 million copies. I think the franchise is making enough money as it is without having to make yet another remake. 



pray4mojo said:
Acevil said:

With full potential of the switch I would say remake of the first one, insanely more money to be made. 

The newest games have already sold 15 million copies. I think the franchise is making enough money as it is without having to make yet another remake. 

Well the question was asked Gen IV or Gen 1, more money can be made on Gen 1. 



 

Acevil said:
pray4mojo said:

The newest games have already sold 15 million copies. I think the franchise is making enough money as it is without having to make yet another remake. 

Well the question was asked Gen IV or Gen 1, more money can be made on Gen 1. 

There are three options in the op's poll. One of them is an entirely new Pokemon game.



pray4mojo said:
Acevil said:

Well the question was asked Gen IV or Gen 1, more money can be made on Gen 1. 

There are three options in the op's poll. One of them is an entirely new Pokemon game.

Oh didn't notice that when I posted, ya  new one I would love first and foremost. 



 

Sinnoh is my favourite region so I'd like to see it with the Gen 7 graphics on the Switch plus we've already had a remake of Gen I.

Around the Network
Why not both?

Although that said gen 1 feels kind of overdone for me. If they were to do it again not only would I prefer a Yellow remake than another Red/Blue, but it would be great if they could make it more than just a Yellow remake. Throw in some other regions too. Johto would be an easy to justify addition, but what about Alola too? Give that some more time in the spotlight and also the new Yellow remake could not only give some nostalgia for gen 1 and the original anime season but it can also give some focus to the Alola anime too.