Jury's still largely out for me, because I'm relatively new using Tinder, but so far it sucks. Wouldn't recommend it. A lot of no-responses, a few dull conversations that went nowhere, a few conversations that went WELL but then they just disappear. Met one person so far where she wanted to meet at some shitty bar at a shitty part of town. She looked nothing like her photo, seemed completely uninterested and the worst part - brought two of her friends. Another chick wanted to get drinks but has cancelled on me twice now..
Pretty close to ditching Tinder and giving OK Cupid a try. My cousin has been using Plenty of Fish and has had a couple decent experiences using it, and a buddy of mine is talking up "Bumble" so may give those a whirl as well.. But I just don't know, I'm starting to feel like you're better off going the old school route and meeting a chick at a bar/club/class/gym, because with these dating sites you're basically taking a gamble and don't know what to expect.
"We hold these truths to be self-evident - all men and women created by the, go-you know.. you know the thing!" - Joe Biden