By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft Discussion - Xbox Scorpio Presentation Spotted at AMD’s CES 2017 RYZEN/Vega Booth

craighopkins said:
Zen architecture is a beast. There are some good videos of legendary Jim Keller explaining what they did

I cant believe as soon as he was done with this chip, he just left again.

AMD should have kept him, hes way to damn tallented.

Even if AMD now knows how to make improvements on zen, and has plans for the future, keeping the guy that played a key role in its design around would have been smart.

 

As I understand it:

Hes the reason Apple smart phone cpu's are so strong,Hes the reason AMD had stronger CPU's than Intel back in the Athlon-64 days.

He was also the coauthor of the specifications for the x86-64 instruction set, and helped amd with its HyperTransport interconnect.

Now he took AMD that had fallen soooooo far behinde intel in CPU, and put them right back to even with them?

You should not let tallent like this leave your company.



Around the Network
JRPGfan said:
jason1637 said:
So what does this mean?

Chance the CPU inside the Scorpio is alot better than what the PS4 has.

The new Ryzen CPUs are faster than Sandy Bridge mhz for mhz, and at lower power.

Its almost even with the fastest current intel cpu's (i7-6900k) (the top end, for Ryzen).

Obviously you dont put that much inside a console, but even a downclocked Ryzen CPU for the scorpio, would be a huge increase in cpu.

Okay thanks.



Eurogamer/Digital Foundry expect a Vega GPU but not a Zen CPU.

"our money is on a downclocked version of AMD's upcoming Vega technology."

"we know of the eight-core Zen is that it's a high-end desktop processor that's likely to require a large area of silicon. Integrating that alongside an already large GPU core seems overly ambitious."

Though I do expect a different CPU in the Scorpio rather than an upclock... so I might still go with Zen.



Ganoncrotch said:

Forza Horizon 4( k ) confirmed for Scorpio launch?

I highly daubt that. Horizon was the name of the event plus history shows 2 years inbetween Horizon titles and 2 years for Motorsport titles. Id expect a Motorsport 7 this year as its FM's turn to release there game.

Just an opinion.



Bandorr said:
pbroy said:
If I was at the booth, I would have acted like I give a shit about whatever this Ryzen crap is to get me that free shirt... 😏

I doubt you can act that well.

Also does the "new horizon" refer to the next Forza game?

The next Forza should be the mainline Forza and not Horizon. 



Around the Network
Vasto said:

Could Project Scorpio possibly be powered by both AMD Ryzen cpu and AMD Vega gpu?

That was always a possibility.

shikamaru317 said:

Wow, if XB1 really has a Ryzen based CPU and Vega GPU it really will be a beast, by console standards at least. We're probably going to be looking at the following performance increases compared to PS4 Pro:

GPU: 42% improvement over PS4 Pro
CPU: Probably at least a 60% improvement over PS4 Pro's Jaguar (AMD is claiming Ryzen is a 40% IPC improvement over Excavator, which itself was 24% improvement over Piledriver, which formed the basis for Jaguar)
RAM: 46% speed improvement, possibly 4 extra GB of RAM as well (12 memory modules were shown on the CGI mock-up of the Scorpio motherboard in the reveal video)

Where did you pluck those numbers from?

mutantsushi said:
Well, OK, confirming everybody's expectations is legitimate too.
I mean, PS4 Pro already was halfway between Polaris and Vega,
and it's not like using Jaguar in 2018 makes sense and Zen is the current AMD offering.
Probably the specific details of memory architecture is biggest unknown, though ditching ESRAM seems a given.

Wishful thinking.
But no.

The Playstation 4 Pro is actually using an older Graphics Core Next design, but it is a semi-custom chip that adopted some good things about Polaris. And adopted nothing from Vega with the exception of FP16 units being bundled together to be processed by the FP32 units.

I don't think you fully comprehend the radical overhaul that Vega is, the PS4 Pro's chip has nothing on it.

JRPGfan said:
jason1637 said:
So what does this mean?

Chance the CPU inside the Scorpio is alot better than what the PS4 has.

The new Ryzen CPUs are faster than Sandy Bridge mhz for mhz, and at lower power.

Its almost even with the fastest current intel cpu's (i7-6900k) (the top end, for Ryzen).

Obviously you dont put that much inside a console, but even a downclocked Ryzen CPU for the scorpio, would be a huge increase in cpu.

Ryzen CPU, well the engineering samples are pretty competitive with the Core i5 6500K/6600K on a core to core basis. Give or take a few hundred megahertz.

In heavily threaded scenario's an 8-Core Ryzen sits in the middle of a Core i7 6-core (6800K) and 8-core (6900K) processor, but uses energy equivalent to the 8-core (6900K), thus Ryzen is less efficient than intel.

But that is also not a bad thing.

AMD will *not* be regaining the performance crown with Ryzen, heck, AMD doesn't even have a high-end chipset/platform that competes with LGA 2011-3 with Ryzen... AMD has also decided to go with a silly L3 cache layout with Ryzen that impacts performance but is a big cost benefit, so you can see the platform is more price-concious.

However, they will offer a stupidly attractive price/performance ratio that hasn't been seen since the Phenom 2 era.

What does this mean for consoles? Absolutely nothing. Scorpio will not be using the latest and greatest, multi-billion transistor, ryzen-based 8-Core/16-thread CPU.
Way to expensive. Way to power hungry. It's not going to happen, so let's nip this in the butt right now. It's just not going to happen. Period. Any rumor that says otherwise is stupid.

Maybe a quad-core configuration though, which will offer 8 threads in total... Or Microsoft might adopt Puma+ which is cheap as chips, small, efficient and allows for a larger GPU.
Or bugger it all and just clock up Jaguar.

craighopkins said:
Zen architecture is a beast. There are some good videos of legendary Jim Keller explaining what they did

Keller is an amazing architect.
Certainly made the Pentium 3 era an interesting one, thanks to his work with the Athlon/Duron.

Sadly, he left AMD a couple of years ago, thankfully after a large portion of Zen was completed.

JRPGfan said:

I cant believe as soon as he was done with this chip, he just left again.

AMD should have kept him, hes way to damn tallented.

Even if AMD now knows how to make improvements on zen, and has plans for the future, keeping the guy that played a key role in its design around would have been smart.

Keller isn't in it for the money. He likes to challenge himself.

He has laid the future foundations for AMD... The only way for AMD to keep being competitive is if they iterate fast enough... They had better not let their platforms stagnate for half a decade like with AM3+. Otherwise they will not be able to regain relevent marketshare and they will fall into obscurity.

With that said, Radeon has now seperated from AMD's CPU devision, so there should be allot more focus now... And there seems to be a general upbeat confident feel to AMD at the moment which is fantastic to see... All they need to do if Zen and Vega are competitive is have a decent marketing team and budget to push the message home.

Barkley said:

Eurogamer/Digital Foundry expect a Vega GPU but not a Zen CPU.

"our money is on a downclocked version of AMD's upcoming Vega technology."

"we know of the eight-core Zen is that it's a high-end desktop processor that's likely to require a large area of silicon. Integrating that alongside an already large GPU core seems overly ambitious."

Though I do expect a different CPU in the Scorpio rather than an upclock... so I might still go with Zen.

I share Eurogamers sentiments on this, since Scorpio was announced.

Vega is the big news though. It will be the largest overhaul of AMD's GPU architecture since Southern Islands and it finally closes the efficiency gap they had with nVidia.
If Scorpio uses Vega technology and not Polaris or older, then that is a massive advantage in Scorpio's favour... I would not be surprised if it doubled the performance of the Playstation 4 Pro in the real world.




--::{PC Gaming Master Race}::--

I think it will be a high clocked custom Raven Ridge cores. A nice enough single thread perf improvement over Kaveri Era Jaguar cores, while keeping thermal/power footprint low to balance out the increased power demands of the GPU.

8 cores of Ravens Ridge at a good enough clock is probably enough to cycle those draw calls in a parallel environment such as DX12/Xbox programming. These cpu are bandwidth bound, and it sounds like they'll have plenty of that around.

Not to mention I still expect some custom underpinnings by Microsoft to optimize a unified memory environment.



PC I i7 3770K @4.5Ghz I 16GB 2400Mhz I GTX 980Ti FTW

Consoles I PS4 Pro I Xbox One S 2TB I Wii U I Xbox 360 S

I think it has under clocked Vega (less Cu then Vega but more CU then Polaris)

If PS4 pro GPU Polaris has 36 CU , with GPU core clock 900 mhz resulting on 4.2 terraflop, Then Vega will have 72 CU (double the Polaris CU). But Xbox One will have 6 terraflop then it's mean, Xbox One logically will have less CU then the Vega and will have similar GPU core clock speed with PS4 pro.

My prediction it will have 54 CU with GPU core clock 900mhz, resulting on 6 terraflop



Pemalite said:

Barkley said:

Eurogamer/Digital Foundry expect a Vega GPU but not a Zen CPU.

"our money is on a downclocked version of AMD's upcoming Vega technology."

"we know of the eight-core Zen is that it's a high-end desktop processor that's likely to require a large area of silicon. Integrating that alongside an already large GPU core seems overly ambitious."

Though I do expect a different CPU in the Scorpio rather than an upclock... so I might still go with Zen.

I share Eurogamers sentiments on this, since Scorpio was announced.

Vega is the big news though. It will be the largest overhaul of AMD's GPU architecture since Southern Islands and it finally closes the efficiency gap they had with nVidia.
If Scorpio uses Vega technology and not Polaris or older, then that is a massive advantage in Scorpio's favour... I would not be surprised if it doubled the performance of the Playstation 4 Pro in the real world.


I am agree with u i  think it has under clocked Vega (less Cu then Vega but more CU then Polaris) 

If PS4 pro GPU Polaris has 36 CU , with GPU core clock 900 mhz resulting on 4.2 terraflop, Then Vega will have 72 CU (double the Polaris CU). But Xbox One will have 6 terraflop then it's mean, Xbox One logically will have less CU then the Vega and will have similar GPU core clock speed with PS4 pro. 

My prediction it will have 54 CU with GPU core clock 900mhz, resulting on 6 terraflop



hudsoniscool said:
FIT_Gamer said:

Nope. It wasn't public.

Do you know who saw it? Journalists or something? Any chance of leaks 

I'll have to search again, but I saw an article saying the slide was just a total of AMD projects for 2017, and not specifically relating Scorpio to RYZEN, but who knows.