By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Is censorship a reason to not buy games?

 

Does censorship stop you from buying games?

Yes 49 52.69%
 
No 44 47.31%
 
Total:93

Depends if you agree/disagree or care/don t care about said censorship.
It can be a good reason to not buy it of course, but people shouldn't just hear "censorship" and then whine without thinking.

As for my personal opinion on recents censorships, I didn t want to buy any of the games Nintendo censored, so I didn t care.
As for south park, I played the pc version without censorship, and frankly the scene they censored isn t a big change. It was supposed to make you laugh, but honestly, the message replacing the scene in the censored version is even funnier. So well.

People don t seem to understand that censure is not always censure. They are mainly compromises, a video game is not the work of one or two guy, you money, a lot of it, and the process itself is long, during that process a lot of "censure" will happen, most of the time its auto-censure. Its just how it is, it s a business, not pure artform.



Around the Network

It depends on what they're censoring. I'd say 98% of the time it wouldn't keep me from buying a game.



Paatar said:
Neodegenerate said:

I do understand the difference and was using the whole "it isnt censorship" argument that you created to the extreme on the other end.  Before I report your post though, let me explain exactly what I mean in a way that you might understand.

This is an example of Localization: Changing Post Office in a jRPG to Bank.  Why?  Because in Japan they do banking business in Post Offices.  In America they do not.  Therefore, to say someone robbed a Post Office in America doesn't make sense.  Change Post to Bank to localize.

This is an example of Censorship: Changing a shirt that shows cleavage to one that doesn't.  There is no reason to do this other than to censor the image.

See the difference? 

Changing a shirt is still localization if they're changing a shirt from a minor. Like Lin in Xenoblade X. That wasn't censorship, that was localization. It's a very controversial thing to have a 13 year old girl in those outfits. If it was a rated M game and she was 18, yet they decided to change it, then it would have been censorship. Localization seen chanhes to fit the culture. It doesn't matter that they're Japanese games so they shouldn't be "butchered". Changing an outfit can be localization or censorship. Depends on the situation. Be lucky we get Japanese RPG's in general. And all in all, if you are upset about boobs getting covered, you really need a different hobby. 

Thank you.

Neodegenerate. Report me for what? I attacked your post not you so what are you reporting? because you don't like it? Ok then whatever. Again there is a difference.



As a general rule, no, but if the censorship goes so far as to make changes that ruin important characters or remove what I consider to be vital gameplay mechanics, then it might get a boycott from me.



Paatar said:
Neodegenerate said:

I do understand the difference and was using the whole "it isnt censorship" argument that you created to the extreme on the other end.  Before I report your post though, let me explain exactly what I mean in a way that you might understand.

This is an example of Localization: Changing Post Office in a jRPG to Bank.  Why?  Because in Japan they do banking business in Post Offices.  In America they do not.  Therefore, to say someone robbed a Post Office in America doesn't make sense.  Change Post to Bank to localize.

This is an example of Censorship: Changing a shirt that shows cleavage to one that doesn't.  There is no reason to do this other than to censor the image.

See the difference? 

Changing a shirt is still localization if they're changing a shirt from a minor. Like Lin in Xenoblade X. That wasn't censorship, that was localization. It's a very controversial thing to have a 13 year old girl in those outfits. If it was a rated M game and she was 18, yet they decided to change it, then it would have been censorship. Localization seen chanhes to fit the culture. It doesn't matter that they're Japanese games so they shouldn't be "butchered". Changing an outfit can be localization or censorship. Depends on the situation. Be lucky we get Japanese RPG's in general. And all in all, if you are upset about boobs getting covered, you really need a different hobby. 

 

1. I agree on the fact that it can be one or the other depending on the sitaution.  However, I am specifically talking about situations where it isn't necessary.  Like the large breasted clearly old enough girls in the M rated Criminal Girls series. 

2.  We live in a global economy, I don't consider myself "lucky" to receive products that are created outside of my country.

3. Nowhere did I say I got upset about anything.  I am making a choice to play the game without paying for it as a way to tell the developers/decision makers that I am not OK with unnecessary censorship in my games.  It has actually taken more time and energy to respond in this thread than it has to think about the censorship thing outside of it in the past like 4 years.

You can spit out all the exceptions to the censorship that point to localization all you want.  It is a weak defense for unnecessary censorship either way.



Around the Network
Veknoid_Outcast said:
Most people neither know nor care about it.

If I went into a GameStop and said to a stranger, "did you hear Tokyo Mirage Sessions is censored?" he or she wouldn't say, "what! That's bullshit." He or she would say "what's Tokyo Mirage Sessions?"

No, s/he would just be uncomfortable and walk away while looking at you weirdly.



Teeqoz said:
Veknoid_Outcast said:
Most people neither know nor care about it.

If I went into a GameStop and said to a stranger, "did you hear Tokyo Mirage Sessions is censored?" he or she wouldn't say, "what! That's bullshit." He or she would say "what's Tokyo Mirage Sessions?"

No, s/he would just be uncomfortable and walk away while looking at you weirdly.

Touche  

Actually I'd be lucky not to get a spray of mace in the face.



To me no, but I can understand if it is for anyone else.



Proud to be the first cool Nintendo fan ever

Number ONE Zelda fan in the Universe

DKCTF didn't move consoles

Prediction: No Zelda HD for Wii U, quietly moved to the succesor

Predictions for Nintendo NX and Mobile


SegataSanshiro said:
Most the time it's not censorship,it's localization. People scream a fit these days. When I was growing up this happened all the time without us knowing and we still loved our games. Also the people typically complaining never planned to buy it. Just trolls.

^

 

Localization changes a lot of things. Not every place has the same general cultures and beliefs



 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

12/22/2016- Made a bet with Ganoncrotch that the first 6 months of 2017 will be worse than 2016. A poll will be made to determine the winner. Loser has to take a picture of them imitating their profile picture.

SegataSanshiro said:
Paatar said:

Changing a shirt is still localization if they're changing a shirt from a minor. Like Lin in Xenoblade X. That wasn't censorship, that was localization. It's a very controversial thing to have a 13 year old girl in those outfits. If it was a rated M game and she was 18, yet they decided to change it, then it would have been censorship. Localization seen chanhes to fit the culture. It doesn't matter that they're Japanese games so they shouldn't be "butchered". Changing an outfit can be localization or censorship. Depends on the situation. Be lucky we get Japanese RPG's in general. And all in all, if you are upset about boobs getting covered, you really need a different hobby. 

Thank you.

Neodegenerate. Report me for what? I attacked your post not you so what are you reporting? because you don't like it? Ok then whatever. Again there is a difference.

If you are gonna say I am "petty and spoiled" (attacks on me, not my post) because of how I choose to spend my money then yes I am going to report you for it.  You don't want to be reported?  Don't go casting aspersions on people.