By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Nintendo Metascore Prediction League 2017: And the Winners Are...

LimaBean01 on 06 October 2017
RavenXtra said:
LimaBean01 said:
Am I allowed to join? I know I'm really late but I only recently made an account, sorry. I know I have no chance of winning but I'd love to do it for fun :)
(Also, predictions for FE:W are still allowed right?)

Absolutely, nothing wrong with having fun

Yes, as long as the game doesn't have a Meta yet, it's okay to predict for.

---

On a side note, Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga is currently at 82 Meta, predictions are closed!

Thanks!! I'll try it out then :p

heres my predictions:

xenoblade chronicles 2: 88

mario odyssey: 98

fire emblem warriors switch: 81

fire emblem warriors n3ds: 70

pokemon ultra sun/moon: 82

etrian odyssey V: 79 (this is literally a random guess lol)

Mario party top 100: 68

I'm hoping xenoblade and FEW switch get higher than I predict :3



https://open.spotify.com/artist/2OUU85T4C3aPPftJhjxEVw?si=Dlo0co2-QKyGJv2cV50X2g

Around the Network
Cerebralbore101 on 08 October 2017
Mar1217 said:
M&L : Superstar Saga DX sits at 82 ... been playing since yesterday and it seriously should have sitted at least in mid 80's. It's a great remake with a new added mode, which is the higlight of this game btw. I guess the series just doesn't have the novelty they wanted from the series.

Let's hope for something great for the Switch !

Welcome to every RPG on the 3DS. They are all excellent but only get metascores of 80-84. Even EO: V will eventually have it's metascore settle in that range. It'll start out strong though and slowly dip over months like all Atlus games on the system. 

What I'm trying to say is, if you like this game I've got ten or twelve RPGs you also might like. :D



EthanWilliam on 09 October 2017

Good



John19 on 11 October 2017

Is it too late to bump Odyssey to a 97?
Also, Mario Party: The Top 100: 70



Cerebralbore101 on 12 October 2017
Cerebralbore101 said:
Cerebralbore101 said:

Etrian Odyssey V: 86

Will probably be better than IV, but most critics will complain over a lack of evolution for the series. Also these games are hard, and a lot of people don't like that. Edit: Playing the Demo. The game has a lot of little improvements such as full blown voice acting, character customization, and races. 

Samus Returns: 88

Looks like a highly polished 2D Metroid. There's no way this won't be a critical darling.

Mario and Luigi: 82

A solid remake.

Pokken Tournament DX: 78

No longer a half assed port, this game gets a lot of upgrades. A complete roster, better framerates, more modes, and portability. Pokken was always a good game, but it needed a proper port from the arcade version. Edit: Lowering my prediction for this one. 

Super Mario Odyssey: 94

I don't see it getting a lower score than this, but I also don't see it being Super Mario Galaxy levels of epic.

Gonna bump Super Mario Odyssey Prediction up to 96.  The game is looking amazing. 

If it's not too late I'm bumping this up to 97 for Odyssey. Jim Sterlling has stopped issueing review scores, and Edge just gave it a 10/10. Those were the two biggest hurdles stopping the game from reaching a ridiculously high score. 



Around the Network
Raven on 16 October 2017
John19 said:
Is it too late to bump Odyssey to a 97?
Also, Mario Party: The Top 100: 70

No, I'll update your score. Edge may have given it a 100, but there still isn't a Metascore so changing is still allowed



VGShare: Screenshot/Gameplay Sharing Thread | Club Nintendo | Official VGC Discord 

Raven on 16 October 2017

Also, just to refresh and update on recent releases:

Final Metas:

- Pokken Tournament DX: 79
- Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga + Bowser's Minions: 82
- Yo-Kai Watch Psychic Specters: 76

Closed Predictions:

-Etrian Odyssey V Beyond the Myth: Currently @ 81



VGShare: Screenshot/Gameplay Sharing Thread | Club Nintendo | Official VGC Discord 

Ryugarr on 16 October 2017

If it isn't too late I would like to also throw my hat in of course on the games that haven't been scored yet.

Super Mario Odyssey: 98

Xenoblade Chronicles 2: 92

Fire Emblem Warriors Switch: 84

Fire Emblem Warriors n3ds: 78

Pokemon Ultra Sun/Moon: 83

Etrian Odyssey V: 81

Mario Party Top 100: 76



LimaBean01 on 16 October 2017
LimaBean01 said:
RavenXtra said:

Absolutely, nothing wrong with having fun

Yes, as long as the game doesn't have a Meta yet, it's okay to predict for.

---

On a side note, Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga is currently at 82 Meta, predictions are closed!

Thanks!! I'll try it out then :p

heres my predictions:

xenoblade chronicles 2: 88

mario odyssey: 98

fire emblem warriors switch: 81

fire emblem warriors n3ds: 70

pokemon ultra sun/moon: 82

etrian odyssey V: 79 (this is literally a random guess lol)

Mario party top 100: 68

I'm hoping xenoblade and FEW switch get higher than I predict :3

you know what, im going to be bullish and raise my fire emblem warriors prediction to 85



https://open.spotify.com/artist/2OUU85T4C3aPPftJhjxEVw?si=Dlo0co2-QKyGJv2cV50X2g

Jranation on 16 October 2017

Mp100 = 78



Pocky Lover Boy!