By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 73 Game Thread - Is that you, Archer?

theprof00 on 27 October 2016
zero129 said:
theprof00 said:

Literally no basis to this post, just conjecture and arrogance.

You think it's perfectly reasonable for me, a mafia godfather, to denounce the uncontested cop's scan instead of just agreeing with you the whole game, and voting off xander.

To quote a certain someone, "are you even listening to yourself?".

 

Isn't it interesting that the only reason you trust spurge is because he's a voice of reason. The only thing that separates mafia and town to you are people who agree with you and people who don't. You think that mafia are only capable of being odd, and townies are only capable of being reasonable. It's pathetic.

Not really i did say when i placed a mess vote on spurge that he could possibly be playing so good this game since his mafia so knows everything.

However im willing to also believe spurge has just really upped his game as town and feel like he wouldnt of switched his vote from Mr.P to trucks if he was on the same team as him since it would of been easier to just leave it there and let the day end.

Now is it possible that spurge is still mafia and has some grander plan?. Yes it is but for me the chances are higher he is town.

You literally just said you confirmed him as town yesterday. You even based your scan on spurge's reasoning. You said so yourself. I can link you to it.
But now you said that spurge is town because he switched his vote from mrp to trucks, but you only figured out that trucks was scum today, so yesterday, him switching his vote to trucks shouldn't have made any difference to you.

I'm curious though about that vote-switch though. I don't think spurge ever actually intended to lynch mrP. He didn't even switch, he voted and then unvoted, and then later voted what linkz voted.

Now, this shouldn't inherently mean he's town either. In most games as mafia, I'll vote for my own teammates as well, so.



Around the Network
theprof00 on 27 October 2016

The list is growing:
1. Still waiting on that post where I said spurge was town
2. Waiting to hear exactly what steel told you (paraphrased so u don't get modkilled.)



theprof00 on 27 October 2016

Iirc we had a game with a cop who got no scan and then we ended up lynching a townie and then him as well because he didn't understand his pm from the mod.



theprof00 on 27 October 2016

I want to know what your role does.
Does it say "find out whether a player is town or not"
Does it say "find out if they are town or mafia"
Does it say "a correct scan will result in guilty"

And then what was your result?
Does it say find out if a player is town or not, and then you got a message saying no result?



theprof00 on 27 October 2016

I protected zero



Around the Network
theprof00 on 27 October 2016

Yeah trucks didn't vote zero either. I forgot, that was one of my points why I thought his defense was weak



Mr.Playstation on 27 October 2016
theprof00 said:
Mr.Playstation said:

I'll just answer to the parts which interest me:

1) Which two players are you referring to, I kind of have an idea but just want to confirm.

2) Most of the time it's players with potential but who don't talk a lot day 1 that end up getting killed (SuperMario Round 71 and Axumblad Round 72). Atleast that's how it's been for all of the three (Now) games I've played. It's why I think Zero isn't cray cray for soft claiming his role. After all the hubba with Prof, I think he thought he would be untouchable. Don't see why it would be any different now. This point is more of a complementary point as why Zero is porbably a cop.

3) Looking back (I do this a lot) Prof wasn't buddying with Linkz, that's my fault for not re-reading the thread because I was in a hurry. I disinctively remembered Prof saying he was biased towards Linkz and that's how I made a connection. Next time please do not be so ambigiuous (Everyone says something wrong especially when pressured to talk)

4) Xander and someone whoose telling him to shut up.

5) How exactly have I been quiet? I've been just as active as you. Sorry if I was sleeping when everyone started posting a lot.

I have no problem voting for Trucks but I want Zero to talk more about his choice in relation to why I think he scanned Trucks (See my reply to Prof)

1. He's talking about me and zero. He thinks we're manipulating the game with a fake cop or something. Yes, that would be genius. Too bad there's only one genius on that team.

2. That sounds, awkward. Supermario and Axum were likely chosen (haha I chose them actually) because they were unlikely to see any kind of protection. However, in both of those games, there had been no cop on day 1, and the most recent one was vanilla. So, the situations were different. Oftentimes, the mafia simply picks someone they feel either needs to go, or is unlikely to draw any suspicion. I don't know where you got your idea, can you explain, because I'm lost.

3. Thanks, but also I thought it was pretty clear. Oh well :D

4. I don't think anyone's telling xander to keep quiet. xander is drawing so much attention for not saying anything that it would be bad advice.

5. It's true that you were basically quiet, or quieter than some others until late yesterday. If I were to do a post count, I assume it would go zero, prof, spurge (minus the quadra posts), linkz, mrp, trucks, xander

This is the part of Mafia reasoning which goes hand in hand with my logic. A first day kill is often someone who won't draw suspicion but a mafia still wouldn't waste a kill on a noob ( Hence first day kills are people who haven't talked a lot day 1/gotten into any arguments but under normal conditions are excellent players)



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

Mr.Playstation on 27 October 2016
spurgeonryan said:
So does anyone else have a role, out with it.
I am vanilla town.

By the way^

I'm not liking this. Why do you just assume everyone's going to believe you? Prof and Zero have some sort of proof but you don't. You just look like you're piggybacking off the other two.



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

Mr.Playstation on 27 October 2016
spurgeonryan said:
believe that I am a vanilla town?


ummmmm....

How is this an appropriate response?



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

Mr.Playstation on 27 October 2016
spurgeonryan said:
What is your role mr.p?

then we will see how far fetched my claim is.

I'm not saying it's far fetched (In fact all remaining town roles must be vanilla now), I'm just saying why do you just accept me/us to believe you? 

I'm vanilla town as stated in my E-mail but I definately don't expect people to believe me 'cause that would be stupid.

How are you so confident?



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P