By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 72 - Six Suspects

Ok just my thoughts catching up with what's been posted today. I'll look over axum later and see what reason could exist for him dying, though I doubt it'll turn up anything fruitful.

 

1. zero's feeling about me being town because I didn't let him get lynched is a little misplaced. Just because I didn't let him die doesn't mean he should think I'm town. In fact, he knows how devious I am lol. I could easily be saving him to make him an ally, or to just make me look like a safe townie.

2. Mr.P's post is setting off all kinds of alarms. First of all, he seems to be intentionally misreading what I wrote yesterday, because I never casted shade on axum, I was actually casting shade on Mr.P for parroting what Axum said. I also am entirely unclear on what would make me think they were on the same team. The entire analysis seems like it has very little actual thought put into it. While I do agree that zero's analysis isn't very grounded, I can't get around this idea that is somewhat non-sequitorially dropped in there of a 2 mafia team and a killer who purposely made no attack last night.

This bothers me for a couple reasons. It seems entirely out of place, like, there was no real reason to suddenly assume multiple killers. It also makes the suspect pool very large, with 3 suspects out of 4 assuming he's leaving himself out of that pool purposely. It also bothers me that there is an assumption of 2 mafia. This specifically bothers me because let's just imagine for a second that Mr P is the silent killer. If he makes no kill himself, he then wakes up to see a kill. That would confirm a second party to a killer. But to the killer, it would seem too easy to just kill the mafia off in one night, which would lead to another assumption that there has to be more than one to be fair to the players.

3. I'd like some clarification about the 'alignment and looking for someone' comment.

HoS: Mr. P



Around the Network
theprof00 said:

Ok just my thoughts catching up with what's been posted today. I'll look over axum later and see what reason could exist for him dying, though I doubt it'll turn up anything fruitful.

 

1. zero's feeling about me being town because I didn't let him get lynched is a little misplaced. Just because I didn't let him die doesn't mean he should think I'm town. In fact, he knows how devious I am lol. I could easily be saving him to make him an ally, or to just make me look like a safe townie.

2. Mr.P's post is setting off all kinds of alarms. First of all, he seems to be intentionally misreading what I wrote yesterday, because I never casted shade on axum, I was actually casting shade on Mr.P for parroting what Axum said. I also am entirely unclear on what would make me think they were on the same team. The entire analysis seems like it has very little actual thought put into it. While I do agree that zero's analysis isn't very grounded, I can't get around this idea that is somewhat non-sequitorially dropped in there of a 2 mafia team and a killer who purposely made no attack last night.

This bothers me for a couple reasons. It seems entirely out of place, like, there was no real reason to suddenly assume multiple killers. It also makes the suspect pool very large, with 3 suspects out of 4 assuming he's leaving himself out of that pool purposely. It also bothers me that there is an assumption of 2 mafia. This specifically bothers me because let's just imagine for a second that Mr P is the silent killer. If he makes no kill himself, he then wakes up to see a kill. That would confirm a second party to a killer. But to the killer, it would seem too easy to just kill the mafia off in one night, which would lead to another assumption that there has to be more than one to be fair to the players.

3. I'd like some clarification about the 'alignment and looking for someone' comment.

HoS: Mr. P

I way out of my depth here, lol. I'll come up with a response tomorrow morning regarding point No.2 ( Currently 00:45 AM here irl time ). I don't want to get myself killed ( Even though my alert self doesn't seem to be doing such a food job at staying alive either )

 

The "Alignment and looking for someone comment" was talking about the fact that since I'm going on the assumption that two mafia players are in this game they obviously have their own chat and so know who is in their team. The killer is obviously going solo in a game of six. That leaves two town left who have absolutely no way to contact each other. Personally I think it's Spurge and me.

 

Also could you please tell me what HoS is short for as I have no idea. Thanks.

 

 



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

I don't have much of a reaction right now, other than the fact I don't know who this Mr P you guys are talking about.



Well, zero, if it makes you feel any worse about me, I hadn't known that day was going to be up until I checked. I honestly assumed I would've seen a countervote. The initial vote was just a random one meant to spark a reaction, specifically from you because you're hard to read for me. But I was very surprised that I didn't see anyone say anything to stop it. It was only coincidence that when I logged in I saw that day was ending and unvoted.

Did you see the vote? Why didn't you say/do anything?
Same question to the other players, especially spurge and xander.

Xander, perhaps you didn't realize but if you had voted someone you would have saved zero. You mention "I don't have the heart to vote somebody". What did you mean by that?



theprof00 said:
Well, zero, if it makes you feel any worse about me, I hadn't known that day was going to be up until I checked. I honestly assumed I would've seen a countervote. The initial vote was just a random one meant to spark a reaction, specifically from you because you're hard to read for me. But I was very surprised that I didn't see anyone say anything to stop it. It was only coincidence that when I logged in I saw that day was ending and unvoted.

Did you see the vote? Why didn't you say/do anything?
Same question to the other players, especially spurge and xander.

Xander, perhaps you didn't realize but if you had voted someone you would have saved zero. You mention "I don't have the heart to vote somebody". What did you mean by that?

I feel like the accusations against Zero were a bit un founded, but that didn't mean I should vote somebody to die just to save him.



Around the Network
XanderXT said:
theprof00 said:
Well, zero, if it makes you feel any worse about me, I hadn't known that day was going to be up until I checked. I honestly assumed I would've seen a countervote. The initial vote was just a random one meant to spark a reaction, specifically from you because you're hard to read for me. But I was very surprised that I didn't see anyone say anything to stop it. It was only coincidence that when I logged in I saw that day was ending and unvoted.

Did you see the vote? Why didn't you say/do anything?
Same question to the other players, especially spurge and xander.

Xander, perhaps you didn't realize but if you had voted someone you would have saved zero. You mention "I don't have the heart to vote somebody". What did you mean by that?

I feel like the accusations against Zero were a bit un founded, but that didn't mean I should vote somebody to die just to save him.

FoS Xander

who can tell me why I FoS xander here

(Also, voting someone else would have made it tied, meaning nobody would die)



theprof00 said:
XanderXT said:

I feel like the accusations against Zero were a bit un founded, but that didn't mean I should vote somebody to die just to save him.

FoS Xander

who can tell me why I FoS xander here

(Also, voting someone else would have made it tied, meaning nobody would die)

zero129 said:
theprof00 said:

FoS Xander

who can tell me why I FoS xander here

(Also, voting someone else would have made it tied, meaning nobody would die)

First of all im pretty sure its since he knows that if he voted someone else nobody would of died?. Or is Xander new to mafia?.

If his new and wouldnt know this i honestly dont know why your FoS'ing him??.

FoS? What's that?

And I know voting somebody would tie the vote, but there's a still a chance that Zero was a mafia.



zero129 said:
XanderXT said:

FoS? What's that?

And I know voting somebody would tie the vote, but there's a still a chance that Zero was a mafia.

FoS = "Finger of Suspicion " .

So you where willing to lose a possible town member just in the hope that with a 1 in 6 chance you would get a mafia member?.

You where willing to take the chance of losing two possible town members bringing the game down to 4 players in the hope you would of got a mafia member.

Double Power HoS Xander

Yes. I thought the benefits outweighed the disadvantages.



zero129 said:
XanderXT said:

Yes. I thought the benefits outweighed the disadvantages.

How exactly is there any benefit to losing two town members on the small chance one might turn up as mafia?.

Less suspects, and the game will be shorter.



I get that it's the weekend, but just a couple posts would be cool