By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Is Taylor Swift the most overrated singer of all time?

 

Who is best

Katy Perry 23 26.14%
 
Taylor Swift 34 38.64%
 
other, explain in comments 31 35.23%
 
Total:88

To be honest she's not even that good looking. She's "pretty" but she's not exactly a knock out, so it ain't the looks. 

Ditto for Bieber ... he's not that talented. 

Say what you want about say a .... Mariah Carey, probably the 90s equivalent to a Taylor Swift, but she has more musical talent in her pinky than these two combined (she can *sing*). 



Around the Network

Looks shouldn't matter.

Also, both Katy Perry and Taylor are extremely overrated.



 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

12/22/2016- Made a bet with Ganoncrotch that the first 6 months of 2017 will be worse than 2016. A poll will be made to determine the winner. Loser has to take a picture of them imitating their profile picture.

Taylor Swift is obviously very overrated but is still 100 times better than Katy Perry in almost every sense. Katy Perry is pure garbage.

At least 1989 is a decent pop album, empty and superficial, but decent, Katy Perry albums however are an absolute overproduced torture and her live voice is horrible.



LurkerJ said:
Taylor Swift is known for writing her music though. I don't like her work but it's all hers.

Katy Perry on the other hand, is one of Dr.Luke products. He literally produced every single hit she released.

Amazing what a legal battle can teach you about music

Other people write her songs too, it's not ''all hers''.



Turkish said:

1. her songs are terrible, all of her songs sound the same, her voice is annoying

I wouldn't say terrible at all, but they're not my thing.  No, she's not a good singer, but she's a good entertainer.


2. she isn't that attractive

She's actually very cute when she doesn't over do it with that stupid make-up she favors, and she has pretty legs, so...


3. her music videos are boring and uninspired

Again, not a fan, but when she's showing off her legs or painting her toes, her videos are fine.

 

Katy Perry ftw!

1. amazing voice, amazing range, lots of different tunes

Definitely a better singer, still not a fan of her music.  I do like more of her songs than Taylor's though.


2. she's hot af

Yes, she's a doll face and is very sexy.


3. her music videos are visually very pleasing

Well, California Gurls is certainly very visually pleasing.



Around the Network
Metroid33slayer said:
LurkerJ said:
Taylor Swift is known for writing her music though. I don't like her work but it's all hers.

Katy Perry on the other hand, is one of Dr.Luke products. He literally produced every single hit she released.

Amazing what a legal battle can teach you about music

Other people write her songs too, it's not ''all hers''.

I know she collaborates,  but for example, Blank Space, probably her most successful song, is all hers. One of her albums was entirely written solo by her, no collaborations. I am strictly talking about writing though, producing and mixing is another story. 



both are same to me

one moans a lot while the other screams a lot



Tsubasa Ozora

Keiner kann ihn bremsen, keiner macht ihm was vor. Immer der richtige Schuss, immer zur richtigen Zeit. Superfussball, Fairer Fussball. Er ist unser Torschützenkönig und Held.

The only female singer I listen to would be that of Fleetwood Mac. As for most overrated I would believe that would go to The Jonas Brothers. I even remember some little fuck on this forum stating they were the best band ever.



kljesta64 said:


one moans a lot while the other screams a lot

Sounds like a porno.



No.