By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Is Taylor Swift the most overrated singer of all time?

 

Who is best

Katy Perry 23 26.14%
 
Taylor Swift 34 38.64%
 
other, explain in comments 31 35.23%
 
Total:88

1. her songs are terrible, all of her songs sound the same, her voice is annoying

2. she isn't that attractive

3. her music videos are boring and uninspired

 

Katy Perry ftw!

1. amazing voice, amazing range, lots of different tunes

2. she's hot af

3. her music videos are visually very pleasing



Around the Network

Both of them are overrated, though they're far from the most overrated singers of all time.



Send a Friend Request On PSN :P

Turkish said:

1. her songs are terrible, all of her songs sound the same, her voice is annoying

2. she isn't that attractive

3. her music videos are boring and uninspired

 

Katy Perry ftw!

1. amazing voice, amazing range, lots of different tunes

2. she's hot af

3. her music videos are visually very pleasing

For a second I though you were serious. Yes, Taylor does not deserve her success at all and seems like a terrible person.

No, Katy is just as bad in terms of talent.



While I do think Taylor Swift success is out of proportion with her musical talent, you lost me with the comparison to Katy Perry. If anything, her songwriting talent is inferior to Ms. Swift. And I don't think physical appearance should have anything to do with this conversation.



What does how attractive someone is have to do with music?

But anyway, I like her songs, neither of them is extremely talented vocally, however I like Taylor Swift's songs more than most Katy Perry songs.

I'd like to know how Mean, Shake it off, Safe and Sound and Blank Space sound remotely similair though.



Around the Network

Neither one of them seem to be anything special. Just two more in a long line of people who have tapped into pop stardom.

I do like Katy's personality more, though.



Taylor Swift is known for writing her music though. I don't like her work but it's all hers.

Katy Perry on the other hand, is one of Dr.Luke products. He literally produced every single hit she released.

Amazing what a legal battle can teach you about music



Yes for Swift but Maybe for Katy Perry.



Pocky Lover Boy! 

I say Beyonce, really talented person, but extremely overrated.



 

Acevil said:
I say Beyonce, really talented person, but extremely overrated.

Absolutely agreed, she has some talent but a lot of her songs are just.... I mean IS THIS MUSIC!?!??!!?