MTZehvor said:
pokoko said: You know, honestly, the focus on improving the situation for African Americans kind of annoys me. There are more white people living in poverty in the United States than black people. There are more Latino people living in poverty in the United States than black people. The focus should be on providing more opportunities for people to pull themselves up, regardless of race. When you're on the bottom, you don't give a damn about percentages.
|
At some level, I agree. I'm not advocating for "let's fix things for black people" and forget about everything else. More than anything, this thread is trying to elaborate on why relations between African Americans and police have been and currently are so high, and what could be done to improve that problem. Ideally, the solution would benefit all races, not just blacks.
With that said, I feel the need to address the bolded, because the way you've phrased it is just misleading. Yes, there are more white people in poverty in the US. There are also far more white people living in the US in general. We would expect a demographic that makes up 62% of the country's population to have the most poor people, the most rich people, and the most middle class people. It's simply by virtue of being the biggest population. Only 9.9% of whites live in poverty, however, compared to 26.6% of Hispanics and 27.8% of blacks. Poverty affects minorities far more disproportionately than it does whites.
|
Misleading? It's not misleading, it's a fact. In absolutely no way did I suggest that the percentages were higher or equal; in fact, I said "when you're on the bottom, you don't give a damn about percentages." You're going to have to explain to me how anything I said was misleading.
Seriously, people are people, they're not ratios, they're not percentages. Someone in that 9.9% is every bit as important as someone in that 27.8% and vice versa.
That need to label and sort people by secondary demographics is part of the problem. You're telling one group that they're a special case, they should get used to assistance, they should depend on it, that they need it more because of the color of their skin. It's ultimately condescending and debilitating. On the other hand, you're telling another group that they don't matter as much because more people with their skin color are successful. They're the chaff, they're the acceptable margin of loss.
Yet another layer of division that just adds to the feelings of resentment.
The goal should be to treat everyone the same, not to keep pushing in a wedge until the gulf is unspannable and you've got two sides looking at each other with suspicion and jealousy. It should be as simple as people who need help, not people who deserve help more because of percentages.