By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Politics Discussion - EU referendum -UK users

 

Leave or remain

Leave 412 53.72%
 
Remain 355 46.28%
 
Total:767

Breexit has to happen



REQUIESCAT IN PACE

I Hate REMASTERS

I Hate PLAYSTATION PLUS

Around the Network
Louie said:
Scisca said:

I said sane and reasonable.

When I look at Germany, I'm starting to see the same arrogance that lead them to start the First and Second World War. They are objectifying other countries and treating them like tools and pawns on their gameboard, not sovereign partners. Look at the immigrant crisis - they are violating and ignoring existing laws. Cause they are Germany - they don't give a f*** about laws if they don't like these laws. Now they are forcing the mandatory automatic distribution of migrants that they invited to Europe - despite no legal basis for this. They use political and economic blackmail to force other countries to deal with the consequences of their mistakes. Genuine spirit of European cooperation.

Don't mix up Germany or the general population and the german government. Merkel is under a lot of criticism here and the way she handled immigration is the reason why her party went from 40%+ in polls to just around 30%. Ironically, it was WWII guilt that pushed Merkel into embracing large numbers of immigrants without a plan. I'm pro-immigration leaning by the way. But the way Merkel handled this was desastrous. That "immigration deal" she reached with Turkey was just another case of her dropping the ball. 

I thought Merkel was doing a decent job during her first and second term in office but right now? Hell no. The current immigration crisis (again: without any sort of plan), the resurgence of the far-right political wing in Germany, the Turkish President getting involved in german politics because Merkel depends on his mercy (to keep the borders shut), worsening of EU relationships (very pro-european guy here)... and all that because Merkel spontaneously said "we can do this!" when asked about immigrants from Syria and other countries. And after that she was too stubborn to aknowledge she made a mistake with that statement. 

As for being more on-topic: What Europe really needs in my opinion is an actual, democratically elected Parliament that has actual power. Europe needs more democracy, not more than two dozen nation state governments battling it out. It's not the european people who are the problem. It's the political elite. I want Britain to stay but I can't blame the 50% who want to leave considering the current state of the union. 

Hats off. 



Louie said:
Scisca said:

I said sane and reasonable.

When I look at Germany, I'm starting to see the same arrogance that lead them to start the First and Second World War. They are objectifying other countries and treating them like tools and pawns on their gameboard, not sovereign partners. Look at the immigrant crisis - they are violating and ignoring existing laws. Cause they are Germany - they don't give a f*** about laws if they don't like these laws. Now they are forcing the mandatory automatic distribution of migrants that they invited to Europe - despite no legal basis for this. They use political and economic blackmail to force other countries to deal with the consequences of their mistakes. Genuine spirit of European cooperation.

Don't mix up Germany or the general population and the german government. Merkel is under a lot of criticism here and the way she handled immigration is the reason why her party went from 40%+ in polls to just around 30%. Ironically, it was WWII guilt that pushed Merkel into embracing large numbers of immigrants without a plan. I'm pro-immigration leaning by the way. But the way Merkel handled this was desastrous. That "immigration deal" she reached with Turkey was just another case of her dropping the ball. 

I thought Merkel was doing a decent job during her first and second term in office but right now? Hell no. The current immigration crisis (again: without any sort of plan), the resurgence of the far-right political wing in Germany, the Turkish President getting involved in german politics because Merkel depends on his mercy (to keep the borders shut), worsening of EU relationships (very pro-european guy here)... and all that because Merkel spontaneously said "we can do this!" when asked about immigrants from Syria and other countries. And after that she was too stubborn to aknowledge she made a mistake with that statement. 

As for being more on-topic: What Europe really needs in my opinion is an actual, democratically elected Parliament that has actual power. Europe needs more democracy, not more than two dozen nation state governments battling it out. It's not the european people who are the problem. It's the political elite. I want Britain to stay but I can't blame the 50% who want to leave considering the current state of the union. 

I know it's the politicians, but if you keep supporting this government, you'll get the blame as well. I know Merkel is losing support, but the support is still huge and she'll probably keep power after the upcoming elections, despite holding on to her current policies. Merkel was getting the job done for a long time, even we were respecting her, but the last couple of years it all changed. To us it seems like, yet again, you've reached the point in which you (as a country, not individual people) no longer want to be "one of the European countries", but you want to be in charge of Europe. To dominate and govern it. The immigration policy is terrible and shows clear signs of that. You keep messing up, violating the law left and right and are forcing others to deal with the outcome. The way the crisis in Greece is being dealt with is again a terrifying display of your power over other countries. Poor Greeks. Your developing cooperation with Russia that's harmful for Central European members of the EU is another burning point. It totally killed any hopes for a united and solidary Europe over here. We see countries only have to show solidarity, when Germany needs it (eg. immigrants), but when it's time for Germany to show it (eg. Nord Stream I and II), you're nowhere to be seen, doing your business as usual and showing other member states the middle finger.

At this point, if we ever want the dream of a happy and united Europe to return, Germany has to take a huge step back. You need to tame your ambitions, cause it's starting to get toxic. But I somehow can't see it happening. With great power comes great responsibility, you seem to want the first one, but don't want to have nothing to do with the second one.

I don't think a new form of the European Parliament would change much. We're not one country and blind pushing for stronger integration in current times of huge unrest is a recipe for disaster. I think what we need right now is the contrary - give countries some more space to breathe and respect the diversity and sovereignity of member nations. We're not a federation and never will become one, the sooner the politicians in Brussels accept that, the better.



Wii U is a GCN 2 - I called it months before the release!

My Vita to-buy list: The Walking Dead, Persona 4 Golden, Need for Speed: Most Wanted, TearAway, Ys: Memories of Celceta, Muramasa: The Demon Blade, History: Legends of War, FIFA 13, Final Fantasy HD X, X-2, Worms Revolution Extreme, The Amazing Spiderman, Batman: Arkham Origins Blackgate - too many no-gaemz :/

My consoles: PS2 Slim, PS3 Slim 320 GB, PSV 32 GB, Wii, DSi.

Scisca said:

I know it's the politicians, but if you keep supporting this government, you'll get the blame as well. I know Merkel is losing support, but the support is still huge and she'll probably keep power after the upcoming elections, despite holding on to her current policies. Merkel was getting the job done for a long time, even we were respecting her, but the last couple of years it all changed. To us it seems like, yet again, you've reached the point in which you (as a country, not individual people) no longer want to be "one of the European countries", but you want to be in charge of Europe. To dominate and govern it. The immigration policy is terrible and shows clear signs of that. You keep messing up, violating the law left and right and are forcing others to deal with the outcome. The way the crisis in Greece is being dealt with is again a terrifying display of your power over other countries. Poor Greeks. Your developing cooperation with Russia that's harmful for Central European members of the EU is another burning point. It totally killed any hopes for a united and solidary Europe over here. We see countries only have to show solidarity, when Germany needs it (eg. immigrants), but when it's time for Germany to show it (eg. Nord Stream I and II), you're nowhere to be seen, doing your business as usual and showing other member states the middle finger.

At this point, if we ever want the dream of a happy and united Europe to return, Germany has to take a huge step back. You need to tame your ambitions, cause it's starting to get toxic. But I somehow can't see it happening. With great power comes great responsibility, you seem to want the first one, but don't want to have nothing to do with the second one.

I don't think a new form of the European Parliament would change much. We're not one country and blind pushing for stronger integration in current times of huge unrest is a recipe for disaster. I think what we need right now is the contrary - give countries some more space to breathe and respect the diversity and sovereignity of member nations. We're not a federation and never will become one, the sooner the politicians in Brussels accept that, the better.

I feel you, man. I totally get where you're coming from. Some points:

1) I'm not supportive of our current government and most people over here are very cirtical towards it. The problem is this: There's almost no way to elect a new government because the two largest german parties (Social Democrats (SPD) and Christian Democrats (CDU)) formed a "Grand Coalition". There's no viable political alternative, with two exceptions: The AfD (which is more and more becoming a far-right party) and the Greens who actually won the federal state elections in south-west Germany earlier this year (SPD and CDU together lost more than 20% of votes compared to 2011 in those elections). So yeah, you're probably right: Merkel might very well still be chancellor after next year's general elections even if her party loses lots of support.

2)  I agree about germany steamrolling other european nations right now. But I'm not sure where the "cooperation with Russia" idea comes from. German media has been very anti-Russia for years now and the general media consensus is that Putin is undemocratic. Whenever Russia hosts a sports even there are discussions about boycotting it and  our secretary of state is opposed to getting Russia back into G7 meetings. It probably looks different from your point of view (naturally, considering the german-russian "track record" when it comes to Poland).

3) At the bolded part: Totally agree. This is something that has bugged me for years. German politicians have been very power-averse for decades because of WWII and now they have no idea how to balance the influential position germany has in european politics. 

4) I guess we agree to disagree on the EU part, then. In my opion there are two ways out of the current situation: A real democratic european reform or a strong scale-back of all things EU. Just not the current bureaucracy. 



Louie said:

I feel you, man. I totally get where you're coming from. Some points:

1) I'm not supportive of our current government and most people over here are very cirtical towards it. The problem is this: There's almost no way to elect a new government because the two largest german parties (Social Democrats (SPD) and Christian Democrats (CDU)) formed a "Grand Coalition". There's no viable political alternative, with two exceptions: The AfD (which is more and more becoming a far-right party) and the Greens who actually won the federal state elections in south-west Germany earlier this year (SPD and CDU together lost more than 20% of votes compared to 2011 in those elections). So yeah, you're probably right: Merkel might very well still be chancellor after next year's general elections even if her party loses lots of support.

2)  I agree about germany steamrolling other european nations right now. But I'm not sure where the "cooperation with Russia" idea comes from. German media has been very anti-Russia for years now and the general media consensus is that Putin is undemocratic. Whenever Russia hosts a sports even there are discussions about boycotting it and  our secretary of state is opposed to getting Russia back into G7 meetings. It probably looks different from your point of view (naturally, considering the german-russian "track record" when it comes to Poland).

3) At the bolded part: Totally agree. This is something that has bugged me for years. German politicians have been very power-averse for decades because of WWII and now they have no idea how to balance the influential position germany has in european politics. 

4) I guess we agree to disagree on the EU part, then. In my opion there are two ways out of the current situation: A real democratic european reform or a strong scale-back of all things EU. Just not the current bureaucracy. 

1) Yeah, you sure have a problem there. Personally, I don't mind Merkel in general, she was fine for years (and that says a lot when it comes from a Pole ). If she went back on the mistakes she made in the last couple years, I wouldn't have a problem with her. But the way she's operating now - I can't accept that. It's a pity you have no alternative, the AfD is also very controversial and potentially dangerous - I don't like this movement, hope it dies. I hope a new quality emerges from somewhere, somehow or Merkel comes to senses.

2) Listern to Steinmeier and Schroeder. Look at Nordstream 1 and 2 - all Central Europe is protesting, from Estonia to Croatia and Romania. Look at Germany blocking the movement of US bases to Poland and the Baltics - you are sending a clear signal, that our safety is worth less to you than good relations with Russia and the money American soldiers spend in Germany. And then you dare to demand solidarity when it comes to immigrants...

Your politicians are playing a game in which they are criticising Russia and throwing big words left and right, but when it comes to economy, you are cooperating. You are the European ambassadors of Gasprom. Granted, overall in the last couple of years you have somewhat distanced yourself from Russia - I'll give you that, cause I've noticed this among my German friends. Unfortunately when it comes to major geo-political projects, you are still tight and you are doing it by putting Central Europe in jeopardy and showing us that there is no "European solidarity" to be found here. It's pure business and we better know our place.

4) I think that you have to know when to do what. Flexibility is the key. Right now we're in a state of crisis on so many fronts, that asking for further integration is madness, because people won't agree to it. I'm not saying it's a bad idea, I'm saying it's a bad time. You have to know when to let lose and when to pull back - it's like seducing a girl We can get back to further strenghtening the cooperation once we get pass the economic crisis, migrant crisis and internal muslim terrorism crisis. Countries and nations aren't willing to give up sovereignity in such times, but when the weather is fine, they'll be more happy to do it, if they see if benefits them instead of introducing new dangers.



Wii U is a GCN 2 - I called it months before the release!

My Vita to-buy list: The Walking Dead, Persona 4 Golden, Need for Speed: Most Wanted, TearAway, Ys: Memories of Celceta, Muramasa: The Demon Blade, History: Legends of War, FIFA 13, Final Fantasy HD X, X-2, Worms Revolution Extreme, The Amazing Spiderman, Batman: Arkham Origins Blackgate - too many no-gaemz :/

My consoles: PS2 Slim, PS3 Slim 320 GB, PSV 32 GB, Wii, DSi.

Around the Network
StokedUp said:
I choose leave, yes it might be a hard year or 2 to start off with while the country adjusts to being fully independent and fully in control of itself but in the long run this presents an opputunity to really make something great of it. Look at Norway, Finland and Sweden, those countries are not part of the EU but do have a deal to do trade and business with eu countries freely and every year those countries are voted in the top 10 best countries to live in every year.

We have a chance to to take back control and make our own rules for our own people.

Just for your information. Finland is in the euro zone, they even use the EURO!! Sweden is also part of Euro zone, but they decided just like the UK to use their own currency!!! (so gone is your comparisement as Finland and Sweden have a high standard of living)

 

I'm Dutch so I will not vote. My personally feeling would be: You are completely right to leave. A lot of the Dutch people would want to leave.

But in reality, most of the people who want to leave(all european countries) only have the feeling that leaving would stop refugees/immegrants and also will give them more money back. Especially the people I speak in the UK, think they pay most per person in Europe and don't get money back etc etc. But that's not true, they are on the 8th spot (after spot 10 you get more money from Europe than giving). https://inews.co.uk/explainers/charts/much-uk-pays-eu-much-get-back/    But in reality when you suddenly step out, this will for sure will cause a economic dip for at least 5 years. And it's expected that because when you leave the EURO this will cause issolation in Europe, the  price to get goods in the country will be much higher than it is now. So the big question is, does the UK have enough own resources and market to climb out of the big dip they will have, when leaving EUROPE? I personally don't think so, as being an island you really depand a lot on importing and exporting goods and when isolated this will cause a problem.  Norway is quite a different story where they have a huge wealth because of the oil they have and next to that they have had also a big dip, but with their current system they have a good social plan but high tax and extreme high prices for many products which are currently in the rest of Europe dirt cheap!

 




View on YouTube



Although voting will close at 10pm on Thursday, the future of Britain’s relationship with the European Union will not be known until at least nine hours later, at 7 am on Friday.


I am scared :/



LurkerJ said:
Although voting will close at 10pm on Thursday, the future of Britain’s relationship with the European Union will not be known until at least nine hours later, at 7 am on Friday.


I am scared :/

So that's the amount of time they take to come up with a viable plan to rig it so the Remain campaign wins. Hmmm



PSN ID: Stokesy 

Add me if you want but let me know youre from this website

I hope you leave just to see the fall out. And I hope Scotland leaves the UK and joins the EU