If RoTR took the optional tomb segments, made them the core focus of the game, and then scaled back the shootouts by 50%, I would say yes. As it stands, they both feel like decent and yet very unfulfilling experiences; the popcorn chicken of the video game world. I'd have trouble rating one over the other.

If we're talking solely gameplay, like the actual interaction between you and the game, RotTR is hands down the superior.

I like Uncharted 4 but I also think its over rated. Playstation fans are going to lean Uncharted 4 because that's the game they have right now.

It would be when there's 40million+ ps4 users and 21milliin XboxOne users. It'll be the exact same on any multi gaming  forum with those overwhelming numbers from ps4s user base.

The PS4 to Xbox One install base is a 2:1 ratio.

On VGChartz, the PS to Xbox fanbase is more like a 5:1 ratio.

Won't comment yet until I play it this christmas,

Pretty much this, but perhaps the second is better but I prefer all 3 uncharted games over TR 13

The Nintendo fanbase is even bigger than playstation though

PS and Nintendo seem a fairly even split. From what I recall, some polls have showed a Nintendo lead, some a Sony lead. Combined the two of them constitute at least 90% of the forum, I reckon.

Cool. I won't be playing RoTR though to give a valid, 'fair' opinion.

Tomb Raider 2013 had it's moments, but it had some flaws in combat and story, like for example you can't fire from the hip/ blind fire, and the melee is very restricted, on the story part Lara is the only character in the game and everyone else just feels like an afterthought.

Then there's the torture porn, which pretty much everyone before me covered already.

Oh, and the color palette is almost nonexistent.

Overall 8/10 experience for me.

I'll have to wait for ROTTR to give a fair judgement, but so far it doesn't look great for CD.