I'm not. I didn't list any in the poll as I was perhaps to strict in narrowing the options to the ones I see getting the most praise, but Forza 4 is 60fps and it would make the top 10 in my opinion.

Oh I completely agree, Halo 4 looks fantastic and is one of the best looking games of last generation in my opinion. I just wanted to give other games a chance. :P

rise of the tomb raider

While i really like Alan Wake graphics quality overall is a bit mixed with sometimes really mediocre animations, partially not so pretty assets...

Animation quality is important for me, with Mirrors Edge still being one of the most immersive first person games in my opinion.

Art design is something subjective. Let's pick Mirrors Edge again, i love that look, some people hate it.

Then there's the technical side. Like resolution, anti aliasing, lighting, texture quality and all that. Mirrors Edge was one of the better games in 2008, not anymore that much impressive in 360's late live. Deus Ex was pretty disappointing here but had a great design.

All that together makes the graphics experience. So Crysis 2 and 3 for example, while still being technically impressive for the old hardware, maybe not having the best but good animations, are both a bit disappointing in the design part.

Bulletstorm looks awesome.

Gears of War 3, Gears of War Judgment, Forza Horizon.

Gears of War 3 murders everything else, Max Payne 3 and Red Dead Redemption were also jaw dropping beautiful, GTA V too! Alan Wake atmosphere was one to remember aswell.

GTA V and Forza Horizon

Its a shame there isn't going to be a sequel to it.

A small shout-out to El Shaddai. A boring game, and not realistic or anything, but it is damn beautiful to look at and I doubt anyone disagrees with it:

True. I love that game.