Well, this has been fun to go through.
I prefer cartoony-looking games over more realistic games mostly because they just look more interesting, colorful, and creative. I deal with realism 24-7, so playing something with more style ans creativity is just more appealing to me. Plus, as someone who loves to draw and design, this sort of stuff is right up my alley.
Though I don't limit myself to just those. I'm fine with anything that is just fun. It is still gameplay > visuals for me.
Also, you'd be surprised what interesting things you can do with a cartoonish look. Games like Conker's Bad Fur Day and Earthbound have childish appearances, but are either the complete opposite, or hide something darker behind that friendly look.
Either way, whatever you think of my likes and preferences, I wouldn't care
Dance my pretties!
The Official Art Thread - The Official Manga Thread - The Official Starbound Thread